Day 20 - June 5, 2024
Forensic testimony addressed taillight and glass comparisons before Trooper Yuriy Bukhenik testified about investigative evidence and a reported interview with Karen Read.
Full day summary
7:47:361. Ashley Vallier — Direct (Part 2)
Ashley Vallier testified about photographs and mechanical comparisons of plastic fragments, identifying fits that included Piece 1 and the taillight housing as parts of the same larger unit.
3. Christina Hanley — Direct/Cross/Redirect
Forensic scientist Christina Hanley distinguished a physical glass match from other comparisons that were consistent with road glass or taillight material.
Cross175 lines
Christina Hanley Cross-Examination: Glass Comparisons Christina Hanley Alan Jackson
2 sidebars inside this proceeding
- Report Business-Record ObjectionCounsel disputed whether a report qualified as a business record, and the judge declined to admit or permit it to be shown pending review.
- Hearsay in Glass ChartThe judge identified hearsay in chart references to glass retrieved by Trooper Proctor and warned that objections to objectionable questions would be sustained.
Highlights
Christina Hanley Direct Examinationtestimony highlightHanley testified that six glass pieces from Item 7-12 physically matched the drinking glass in Item 3-2 and had once been part of the same unit.Christina Hanley Direct Examinationtestimony highlightHanley testified that bumper-glass Piece E was consistent in physical and instrumental properties with road glass from Item 7-14, while qualifying that either could share those characteristics with another source.Christina Hanley Direct Examination“Accordingly, the examined portion of the piece of clear glass that I labeled as "E" from Item 3-3 could have originated from the examined portion of the piece of clear glass from Item 7-14 or from another source with the same characteristics.”— Christina HanleyStates the qualified association between bumper glass and road glass.
4. Yuri Bukhenik — Direct (Part 1)
Yuriy Bukhenik continued direct testimony about the investigation, evidence handling, surveillance footage, and related court rulings.
Direct1392 lines
Yuriy Bukhenik - Direct Examination Yuri Bukhenik Adam Lally
9 sidebars inside this proceeding
- Witness Use of “We”Counsel objected to the witness's use of “we” rather than identifying individual actions, and the judge declined to sustain the objection.
- Limit on Medical CausationThe judge limited the witness to observations and prohibited medical testimony or opinions about what caused an injury based on experience.
- Clothing Bag Chain of CustodyCounsel raised a chain-of-custody concern about clothing bags, including the orange tee shirt, and the judge said the item would not enter evidence at that point.
- Instructions on Photographs and StatementThe judge discussed instructions for gruesome photographs and a Milton Barracks statement, agreeing not to mention Miranda warnings while requiring the statement to be voluntary.
- Voluntary Statement Jury InstructionThe judge reviewed a proposed instruction on alleged voluntary statements and declined to add a specific reference to medication or mention Miranda warnings.
- Sally Port Video ReviewCounsel disputed whether they had previously received a particular sally port video, and the judge ordered a 10-minute break so it could be reviewed.
- Foundation for Search-Warrant VideosCounsel challenged Sergeant Bukhenik's foundation to testify about search warrants and videos, and the judge directed that a foundation be laid.
- Playing Videos in Exhibit 6Counsel objected that Sergeant Bukhenik lacked foundation for videos in Exhibit 6, and the judge ruled that the videos were in evidence and could be played.
- C.F. McCarthy's Receipt FoundationCounsel objected to foundation for C.F. McCarthy's receipts, and the judge allowed it in connection with the video while noting the objection.
Highlights
Yuri Bukhenik - Direct (Resumed)“Before you may even consider any such statement as evidence, the Commonwealth must prove to you beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant made the statement that she's alleged to have made and that she made it voluntarily, freely and rationally.”— Beverly J. CannoneThe court framed how jurors must evaluate the reported interview statements before hearing them.Voluntary Statement Jury InstructionrulingBefore testimony about Read's reported statements, the court instructed jurors that the Commonwealth must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that any alleged statement was made voluntarily, freely, and rationally.