Evidence
Exhibits and other evidence discussed across both trials.
664 items·1,343 mentions
Key Evidence (6)
Waterfall Bar & Grille Surveillance Video, Jan. 28–29, 2022
Video Evidence
Waterfall Bar security footage from January 28–29, 2022, showing the interior, lobby and parking lot and the movements of Read, O'Keefe, Jennifer McCabe and the Albert–Higgins group.
O'Keefe's Gray Sweatshirt/Hoodie (Item 7-18)
Physical Evidence
O'Keefe's gray hoodie, item 7-18, with nine documented right-sleeve damage areas and stains confirmed as blood. Admitted in a plexiglass encasement in Trial 2.
Ring Video 153 — Lexus Departs Carport, 5:07 AM
Video Evidence
5:07 a.m. Ring footage of the Lexus reversing near O'Keefe's Traverse, with taillight-area damage visible. Aperture analyzed possible contact; replacement of the original camera was questioned on cross.
Cruiser 683 Dashcam — Saraf, 34 Fairview Scene
Video Evidence
Cruiser 683 footage from 34 Fairview on January 29, 2022, showing blizzard conditions, people around O'Keefe, scene tape and Read's damaged taillight.
O'Keefe Right Arm Wound Photo — Primary
Photographs
Right-arm photograph showing linear scratches, parallel furrows and contusions, admitted as Trial 1 Exhibit 19 and Trial 2 Exhibit 1 and shown to fact and expert witnesses.
Broken Cocktail Glass from 34 Fairview Road (Item 3-2)
Physical Evidence
Broken cocktail glass recovered at 34 Fairview using a leaf blower. Six scene fragments physically matched it; bumper pieces A and B did not. Bumper E was consistent with a different road fragment.
Physical Evidence (75)
O'Keefe's Gray Sweatshirt/Hoodie (Item 7-18) — O'Keefe's gray hoodie, item 7-18, with nine documented right-sleeve damage areas and stains confirmed as blood. Admitted in a plexiglass encasement in Trial 2.
Trial 1Trial 219 mentionsBroken Cocktail Glass from 34 Fairview Road (Item 3-2) — Broken cocktail glass recovered at 34 Fairview using a leaf blower. Six scene fragments physically matched it; bumper pieces A and B did not. Bumper E was consistent with a different road fragment.
Trial 1Trial 214 mentionsPassenger-Side Tail Light Housing from Karen Read's Lexus (Item 3-1) — Passenger-side Lexus taillight housing, item 3-1, used for mechanical comparison with scene fragments and exterior DNA swabs. The housing is all plastic, with no glass components.
Trial 1Trial 212 mentionsTaillight Fragments in O'Keefe's Clothing — Microscopic red and clear plastic from O'Keefe's clothing, found consistent with Read's taillight material. The fragments' size and possible role in his injuries were disputed.
Trial 1Trial 211 mentionsGlass Pieces from Defendant's Vehicle Bumper (Item 3-3) — Five glass pieces from the Lexus rear bumper. A and B did not physically match the road samples; E was instrumentally consistent with item 7-14. Hartnett did not know when they reached the bumper.
Trial 1Trial 27 mentionsO'Keefe's Black Nike Sneaker (Recovered at 34 Fairview Road) — Black Nike sneaker found inverted by the curb under snow at 34 Fairview. Its matching shoe was recovered at the hospital; photographs of both were introduced together.
Trial 1Trial 27 mentionsO'Keefe's Clothing Collection from Good Samaritan Hospital — O'Keefe's hospital clothing collection, dried on butcher paper. Both shirts were initially bagged together and separated at an unknown point; the clothing reached the lab March 14.
Trial 1Trial 27 mentionsTaillight Fragments Recovered at 34 Fairview Road — Plastic consistent with taillight material recovered near O'Keefe's body. None was found in the initial search; when and how the fragments reached the scene was questioned.
Trial 1Trial 27 mentionsO'Keefe's Orange T-shirt (Item 7-17) — O'Keefe's orange T-shirt, item 7-17, with five photographed stains confirmed as blood. Recovered from the hospital and admitted in a transparent sleeve in Trial 2.
Trial 1Trial 26 mentionsDNA Swab from Drinking Glass Exterior (Item 3-2.1) — Swab from the broken glass with a three-person DNA mixture including O'Keefe and two unidentified contributors. Porto said he was not asked to compare Brian Albert or Brian Higgins.
Trial 1Trial 25 mentionsHair — Bode Technology mitochondrial DNA results — Bode mitochondrial-DNA testing found the hair consistent with O'Keefe's profile. At 95% confidence, the analyst estimated that at least 99.895% of the population could be excluded.
Trial 1Trial 25 mentionsLab Photographs of Tail Light Housing — Hartnett Examination — Hartnett's laboratory photographs of the removed taillight housing, including measurements. DNA swabs were taken from exterior surfaces, not protected interior areas.
Trial 1Trial 25 mentionsSingle Glass Piece from Road, 34 Fairview (Item 7-14) — Glass recovered from the road on February 11, 2022, instrumentally consistent with bumper piece E but not matching the drinking glass or the nine scene glass pieces.
Trial 1Trial 25 mentionsTrace Debris from O'Keefe's Clothing (Item 7-18.18) — Trace scrapings from O'Keefe's shirts, including apparent fibers, plastic, hair and dirt, collected by Vallier without directly handling the garments and sent to Hanley.
Trial 1Trial 25 mentionsClear Taillight Lens Fragment Found During Search (Exhibit 73) — Photographs of a clear lens fragment. Brennan described it as matching Read's taillight during questioning; Russell said she had not specifically considered it.
Trial 24 mentionsDNA Evidence on Tail Light Housing — DNA analysis of the taillight exterior detected material consistent with O'Keefe, along with additional contributors.
Trial 14 mentionsGround-Level Taillight Fragment at Scene (Exhibit 76) — Ground-level photographs of a taillight piece. O'Hara identified its location; pre-snowfall deposition was a premise in questioning, not a timing conclusion from his testimony.
Trial 24 mentionsItem 7-16: Large Taillight Pieces Collected by Proctor (February 18) — Three mechanically fitting red taillight pieces and clear fragments recovered by Proctor on February 18, 2022. The red pieces measured about 11, 18 and 19 centimeters.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsO'Keefe's Blue Jeans (Item 7-1) — O'Keefe's hospital-recovered jeans, item 7-1, photographed with five red-brown stains, dirt, debris, EMT cuts and grass staining on the left rear.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsO'Keefe's BPD Baseball Hat (Recovered at 34 Fairview Road) — O'Keefe's BPD hat, found frozen flat under about 18 inches of snow at 34 Fairview, absent from the hospital collection and not recovered during the initial SERT search.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsPlastic and Glass Fragments Recovered February 10 — Plastic and glass collected February 10 and booked at the lab March 14. Jackson challenged the custody documentation; Bukhenik disputed that the booking gap meant improper handling.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsRed Solo cups — blood evidence from Fairview Road (physical) — Six red Solo cups of blood-and-snow samples carried in a grocery bag. Gallagher acknowledged alternative methods while citing storm urgency, scene demands and equipment constraints.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsClear Dimpled Plastic Taillight Cover (Count Discrepancy, Exhibit 571) — A bag held two clear, dimpled taillight-cover pieces, while the report described one. The dimples were also noted as potentially relevant to O'Keefe's arm injuries.
Trial 13 mentionsDNA Stain Samples from O'Keefe's Jeans (Items 7-1.2.1–7-1.7.1) — Jeans stains analyzed by Porto supported O'Keefe's inclusion in both trials. An unstained exterior control area yielded a four-contributor DNA mixture.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsItem 7-15: Large Taillight Piece Collected by Proctor (February 11) — A roughly six-by-seven-inch taillight piece, two clear plastic pieces and a debris canister recovered by Proctor on February 11, 2022.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsRed Taillight Fragment Surfaced by Snow Shovel (Exhibit 75) — Photographs of a red taillight fragment on a snow mound, with shovel marks visible, after it surfaced when a searcher overturned a shovel during snow clearing.
Trial 23 mentionsRed Taillight Piece Recovered February 4 — Red taillight-cover plastic found at 34 Fairview on February 4, 2022, about seven feet from the road, as snow began to melt; documented in a photograph.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsScene Fragment Collection: Items 7-5 through 7-16 — Scene plastic, glass and debris catalogued as items 7-5 through 7-16, examined for internal and cross-item matches to assemble composite pieces and identify mechanical fits.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsScene Glass Fragments, 34 Fairview Road (Item 7-12) — Nine glass pieces and five plastic pieces from 34 Fairview. Six glass pieces physically matched the drinking glass; E, I and L did not. E and I physically matched each other.
Trial 13 mentionsScene Photographs: Glass and Blood in Snow (T1 Exh. 27 / T2 Exhs. 52, 52A) — Close-up photographs of broken cocktail glass and blood in snow after leaf-blower clearing at 34 Fairview, used in both trials to document evidence where O'Keefe was found.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsDebris Reconstruction vs. Tail Light Housing Comparison Photographs — Photographs of reconstructed road debris fitted together and positioned against the known taillight housing to demonstrate mechanical fit.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsDNA Stain Samples from O'Keefe's Shirts (Items 7-17 & 7-18 Series) — Porto interpreted 13 selected shirt stains as single-contributor profiles supporting O'Keefe. Separate gray-shirt results included mixtures and three profiles unsuitable for comparison.
Trial 22 mentionsHair root sub-item — MSP item 3-6 — The root end of the human hair recovered from the exterior passenger-side rear panel of Karen Read's vehicle, catalogued as MSP Crime Lab item 3-6.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsHair shaft sub-item — MSP item 3-61 / Bode EO1 — The shaft end of the human hair recovered from the exterior passenger-side rear panel of Karen Read's vehicle, catalogued as MSP Crime Lab item 3-61 and Bode Technology item EO1.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsItem 7-13: Fragments Collected by Proctor (February 8) — Taillight fragments collected by Trooper Proctor on February 8, 2022 comprised one large red plastic piece, one small red plastic piece, and one black plastic piece. These pieces were recovered by Proctor working alone.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsItem 7-8: Fragments Collected by DiCicco (February 3) — Fourteen plastic pieces collected by DiCicco at 34 Fairview on February 3, 2022, documented by a handwritten bag label and photograph, including clear plastic with red and black coloring.
Trial 12 mentionsPhotograph: Item 3-2 Physical Match to Scene Glass (T2 Exh. 195) — A photograph of the broken drinking glass (item 3-2) demonstrating the physical match to a piece from the scene glass collection (item 7-12), used to visually anchor the prosecution's glass-origin analysis.
Trial 22 mentionsRed Hard Plastic Taillight Cover (Count Discrepancy, Exhibit 570) — A bag of red taillight-cover plastic from 34 Fairview contained three pieces when opened at trial, while the investigator's report documented one piece at that location.
Trial 12 mentionsT2 Exhibit 56 — photograph of Solo cups inside bag — A Trial 2 photograph showing red Solo cups inside the open Stop & Shop bag, depicting the blood collection containers in their improvised storage configuration.
Trial 22 mentionsT2 Exhibit 57 — photograph of Solo cups with coagulated blood — A Trial 2 photograph showing the red Solo cups containing coagulated blood, documenting the condition of the biological evidence in non-sterile, unsealed containers.
Trial 22 mentionsT2 Photograph of Tail Light Housing — Hanley (Exhibit 200) — Photograph of the taillight housing as received by the lab. Hanley said most examined parts were plastic but was uncertain about the whole assembly and had not noted glass portions.
Trial 22 mentionsWaterfall Bar Surveillance: O'Keefe with Cocktail Glass at 12:11 a.m. — Surveillance video and still images from the Waterfall Bar & Grille showing John O'Keefe exiting the establishment at 12:11 a.m. holding a cocktail glass, establishing his last known location and physical condition.
Trial 12 mentionsARCCA Analysis of Tail Light Physical Damage — Rentschler — Defense expert Dr. Andrew Rentschler's analysis of the physical damage to the Lexus right rear tail light cover, comparing the observed damage to the damage produced by ARCCA's 15 mph impact testing.
Trial 11 mentionARCCA Pneumatic Cannon Test: Drinking Glass vs. Tail Light — ARCCA cannon tests firing a drinking glass at a taillight at 31 and 37 mph. The 37 mph test replicated the damage pattern on the subject taillight.
Trial 11 mentionBarros Testimony — Tail Light Damage Photograph — Taillight photograph shown to Barros in Trial 2. He reaffirmed that the pictured damage did not match what he had personally observed at the scene.
Trial 21 mentionBlack Plastic Drinking Straw from 34 Fairview Road — A black plastic drinking straw found near the paved berm on the street at 34 Fairview Road, collected as physical evidence from the scene.
Trial 21 mentionClear Plastic Fragments at Ground Level (Non-Taillight) — Pieces of clear plastic, distinct in color from the red taillight fragments, were recovered at ground level at the scene and documented photographically alongside other debris.
Trial 21 mentionDebris Field Near Flagpole and Fire Hydrant (Exhibits 89-94) — Plastic and glass fragments were recovered with photographs documenting their locations near the flagpole and fire hydrant at 34 Fairview Road, spanning the area of the lawn where O'Keefe was found.
Trial 21 mentionDefendant's Lexus SUV — Physical Inspection at 34 Fairview — Karen Read's Lexus SUV presented for jury inspection at 34 Fairview Road, with both attorneys directing jurors' attention to specific features of the vehicle.
Trial 21 mentionDefense Glass Photo Reference Set (T2 Exhs. 52A, 195, 197A-D) — A set of photographs referenced collectively by defense expert Andrew Rentschler, including images of the broken drinking glass found near O'Keefe's body and a glass piece found in the street.
Trial 21 mentionExhibit 146 — Tail Light Housing with Unexplained Loose Pieces — Taillight housing and loose fragments displayed with its evidence bag. Hartnett acknowledged she could not account for having placed the additional pieces there herself.
Trial 21 mentionGlass Fragment Recovered from O'Keefe's Nose — A glass shard discussed in testimony as embedded in the left side of John O'Keefe's nose.
Trial 21 mentionGoode Report: Replacement Taillight Photograph — A photograph of a taillight piece allegedly found at 34 Fairview, identified as a replacement image in a later Goode report rather than a photograph from the original documentation date.
Trial 11 mentionHair on rear quarter panel — multi-view photographs — A series of photographs and zoomed views showing an apparent human hair attached to the exterior rear quarter panel of Karen Read's vehicle prior to collection.
Trial 11 mentionHair recovery location — rear quarter panel photograph — A photograph documenting the location on the exterior rear quarter panel of Karen Read's vehicle where an apparent human hair was recovered.
Trial 11 mentionItem 7-12: Mixed Plastic and Glass with Drinking Glass Matches — Five apparent plastic pieces and nine apparent glass pieces from 34 Fairview. Hanley testified that she believed six glass pieces fit mechanically to a drinking glass recovered from the road.
Trial 21 mentionMcCabe Testimony — Read's Early Awareness of Taillight Damage — Matthew McCabe's testimony that Karen Read mentioned a cracked taillight during early morning phone calls before John O'Keefe was found.
Trial 11 mentionOfficer Barros Observation — Lexus Condition at Dighton (T1) — Barros's documented observation of the Lexus in Dighton before seizure: a cracked taillight with a missing piece and a rear-quarter-panel dent.
Trial 11 mentionPhotograph: Drinking Cup Item 3-2 (T2 Exh. GGG) — A photograph of the drinking cup (item 3-2), used to visually identify the cup as the base item for physical match comparison during trace analyst testimony.
Trial 21 mentionPhotograph: Drinking Straw at 34 Fairview Road (T2) — A photograph of the black plastic drinking straw found in front of 34 Fairview Road, documenting it at the scene.
Trial 21 mentionPhotograph: Glass Fragments on Defendant's Rear Bumper (T1 Exh. 168) — A photograph of apparent glass fragments resting on the surface of the rear bumper of the defendant's vehicle, taken to document their position.
Trial 11 mentionPhotograph: Item 3-3 Bumper Glass with Scale Ruler (T2 Exh. 198) — A laboratory photograph of item 3-3 — five glass pieces recovered from the vehicle bumper — shown with a scale ruler as received by the trace analyst.
Trial 21 mentionPhotograph: Road Glass Piece 7-14 by Vallier (T2 Exh. JJJ) — A photograph of the single glass piece from item 7-14, taken by analyst Vallier, documenting the sole fragment whose refractive index was consistent with bumper glass piece E.
Trial 21 mentionPhotograph: Single Road Glass Piece, Item 7-14 (T2 Exh. 199) — A photograph of item 7-14 — the single piece of clear glass recovered from the road at 34 Fairview Road — taken to document the isolated fragment.
Trial 21 mentionPhotographs: Scene Glass Pieces, Item 7-12 (T2 Exh. 196A-B) — Photographs of item 7-12 — the nine glass pieces recovered from 34 Fairview Road — as received by trace analyst Christina Hanley.
Trial 21 mentionScene Evidence Collection, 34 Fairview Road (Items 7-5 to 7-19) — A collection of apparent plastic pieces, glass pieces, and a drinking straw recovered from 34 Fairview Road and examined for physical matches to the tail light and drinking glass evidence.
Trial 11 mentionT1 exhibits 37–40 — photographs of Solo cups in bag near vehicle — Four Trial 1 photographs taken in the Canton PD sallyport showing red Solo cups containing blood evidence inside a Stop & Shop grocery bag, positioned near the right rear quarter panel of Karen Read's SUV.
Trial 11 mentionT1 Tab 25 — photograph of Solo cups (Lank) — A Trial 1 photograph introduced through Sgt. Lank, appearing to show red Solo cups with red liquid inside.
Trial 11 mentionT1 Tab 26 — photograph of gloved hands opening grocery bag (Lank) — A Trial 1 photograph introduced through Sgt. Lank, showing gloved hands opening the Stop & Shop bag and cups that appeared to be the same Solo cups shown in Tab 25.
Trial 11 mentionT2 Exhibit 55 — photograph of Stop & Shop bag near SUV (Gallagher) — A Trial 2 photograph showing the Stop & Shop bag containing Solo cups of blood evidence positioned near the right rear tire of Karen Read's SUV.
Trial 21 mentionTail Light Damage Comparison Photos — Before and After Proctor Possession — Photographs presented by the defense during closing arguments comparing the appearance of the tail light before and after it passed through investigator Michael Proctor's possession.
Trial 11 mentionTaillight Debris Near Fire Hydrant (Exhibit 492) — A photograph showed a piece of plastic debris located near the fire hydrant at the scene, positioned at a distance from O'Keefe's body.
Trial 11 mentionTaillight Fragment Overview: February 8, 11, and 18 Recoveries — Taillight fragments were recovered from the 34 Fairview Road lawn across three separate collection dates — February 8, 11, and 18 — as snow continued to melt over the weeks following the incident.
Trial 11 mentionTaillight Reconstruction with Missing Section (Exhibit 432) — A photograph of the reconstructed taillight showing a missing section. Vallier said she did not know where the absent pieces were or what happened to them.
Trial 11 mentionUnaccounted Chip Fragment in Taillight Evidence Bag — A small chip found in a taillight evidence bag with two larger pieces. The collector could not explain the additional fragment, having bagged only two pieces at the scene.
Trial 21 mentionPhotographs (131)
O'Keefe Right Arm Wound Photo — Primary — Right-arm photograph showing linear scratches, parallel furrows and contusions, admitted as Trial 1 Exhibit 19 and Trial 2 Exhibit 1 and shown to fact and expert witnesses.
Trial 1Trial 216 mentions34 Fairview Rd — drawing/scale model of property (Exhibit 66/T1) — Drawing or model of 34 Fairview showing the house, windows, doors, garage, driveway, exterior lights and bulkhead, used with several Trial 1 witnesses.
Trial 18 mentions34 Fairview Rd — flagpole, fire hydrant, body position — Photograph of the 34 Fairview lawn, flagpole, bush and hydrant, on which witnesses pointed out where O'Keefe's body had been positioned.
Trial 17 mentionsRight Rear Tail Light Damage — T2 Exhibit 13 (Sallyport) — Sallyport photograph of the Lexus's damaged right rear taillight, showing missing portions and protruding metal, displayed to several Trial 2 witnesses.
Trial 27 mentions34 Fairview Rd — front photo with vehicles (Exhibit 71/T1) — Photograph of the front of 34 Fairview Road showing the house exterior, door locations, and the area where multiple witnesses observed vehicles parked the night of January 28–29, 2022.
Trial 16 mentions34 Fairview Rd — flagpole and mailbox area (Exhibit 72/T1) — Photograph of the front yard area of 34 Fairview Road showing the flagpole, mailbox, and the area where multiple witnesses observed a dark SUV parked.
Trial 15 mentions34 Fairview Rd — scene exterior photo (Exhibit 9/T1) — Photograph of 34 Fairview Road showing the exterior of the Albert residence used by multiple first responders to identify the property and the approximate location where O'Keefe was found.
Trial 14 mentions34 Fairview Rd exterior — general residence photo — Exterior photograph of 34 Fairview showing the front and side doors and property layout, identified by first responders and police witnesses as a fair and accurate depiction.
Trial 14 mentionsMcLaughlin–Albert social photo collection (impeachment set) — Social-media items and photos of McLaughlin and Albert. Trial 1 H–K were excluded under Rule 14; later set S was denied admission. Trial 2 cross used photos without a source exhibit label.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsO'Keefe Gastric Mucosa / Stomach Lining Photo (T2 Ex 164) — Trial 2 stomach-lining photograph showing redness and hemorrhages. Laposata described normal folds with some redness and no Wischnewski ulcers.
Trial 24 mentionsO'Keefe Right Arm — January 31 Autopsy Photo (T2 Ex 167) — January 31 right-arm autopsy photograph. Russell identified postmortem lividity; Laposata said the injuries occurred before death and were consistent with an animal bite.
Trial 24 mentionsO'Keefe Right Eyelid Laceration Photo (T2 Ex 165) — Right-eyelid autopsy photograph. Scordi-Bello said a backward fall onto the back of the head would not cause the laceration; Laposata described horizontal skin splitting from direct force.
Trial 24 mentions1 Meadows Ave — driveway side with Ring camera and garage — Photograph of the driveway side of O'Keefe's house at 1 Meadows Avenue showing the garage doors, Ring camera, and floodlight on the property.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentions1 Meadows Ave — O'Keefe house front exterior — Photograph of the front of John O'Keefe's residence at 1 Meadows Avenue in Canton, used in both trials by multiple witnesses to orient the jury to the victim's home.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentions34 Fairview Rd — exterior with flagpole, daylight contrast (T2 Exhibit 3) — Trial 2 photograph of 34 Fairview, the flagpole and grounds, used to contrast plowed daylight conditions with conditions during the blizzard.
Trial 23 mentions34 Fairview Rd — wider street/SUV movement photo (Exhibit 73/T1) — Wider photograph of 34 Fairview Road and the surrounding street area, used to show subsequent positions of a dark SUV as it moved progressively up the road from the house.
Trial 13 mentionsCedarcrest Rd / Fairview Rd / Chapman St neighborhood map — Map showing the intersection of Cedarcrest Road, Fairview Road, and Chapman Street, used in both trials to orient witnesses and the jury to the local geography, vehicle approach directions, and sightlines.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsColin Albert welcome-home party photos (Feb 11, 2022) — Two February 11, 2022 photographs of Colin Albert at a cousin's welcome-home party at 34 Fairview, one with Nicole Albert and one alone in the library.
Trial 13 mentionsO'Keefe hat recovery site — grass and vegetation beneath (T2 Exs 99C/99D) — Photographs of the site where O'Keefe's hat was recovered, showing yellow grass and brown leaf material beneath the hat and that the hat was frozen flat to the ground.
Trial 23 mentionsO'Keefe Nasal Abrasion Photo (T2 Ex 166) — Autopsy photograph of a left-nose abrasion. Brennan asked about an object allegedly removed from the nose; Rentschler said he believed the material was glass.
Trial 23 mentionsO'Keefe Occipital Laceration Photo (T2 Ex 160) — Autopsy photograph of the back-of-head wound, abrasion and J-shaped mark with a scale. Laposata identified a ridged pattern and granular vertical markings.
Trial 23 mentionsO'Keefe Traverse and garage door photos (T1, Meadows Ave) — Photographs of John O'Keefe's Chevrolet Traverse and the garage doors at 1 Meadows Avenue, including specific photographs of the driver-side rear of the vehicle, taken February 3, 2022.
Trial 13 mentionsScene snow, blood, and footprints photo — Photograph showing the snow-covered lawn at 34 Fairview Road including footprints, blood pooling near O'Keefe's head, and the area where O'Keefe was found.
Trial 13 mentions1 Meadows Ave — O'Keefe driveway view — Photograph of the driveway at 1 Meadows Avenue showing the walkway and breezeway door entrance area, and the layout of the parking area.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentions1 Meadows Ave — O'Keefe vehicle in driveway with Read's car — Photograph of John O'Keefe's driveway showing O'Keefe's vehicle and identifying Karen Read's vehicle parked in the driveway.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentions34 Fairview Rd — area where O'Keefe found (T2 Exhibit 2) — Photograph of the area at 34 Fairview Road where O'Keefe was found, used in Trial 2 to orient first responders' testimony and challenged during cross-examination regarding precise positioning.
Trial 22 mentions34 Fairview Rd — curb/berm area photo (Jan 29) — January 29 photograph of the curb and asphalt berm near 34 Fairview, including snow-cleared ground, used on the first version of Goode's report face sheet.
Trial 12 mentions34 Fairview Rd — front door, flagpole, fire hydrant (Nicole Albert / Paul) — Photograph of the exterior of 34 Fairview Road showing the front door, side door, flagpole, and fire hydrant, used by Nicole Albert and later by Joseph Paul to identify the fire hydrant area.
Trial 12 mentions34 Fairview Rd SERT search photo set — Jan 29, 2022 (Exhibits 111–134/T1) — Photographs taken by Lt. Tully and introduced through multiple witnesses documenting the SERT search of 34 Fairview Road on January 29, 2022, including evidence items in place and the broader search area.
Trial 12 mentionsBroken/Missing Tail Light Photograph — T2 Exhibit 11 — Photograph of Karen Read's vehicle showing broken or missing tail light pieces, shown to Jennifer McCabe and Marie Russell during Trial 2.
Trial 22 mentionsChris Albert with Chief Berkowitz at fundraiser — Photograph of Chris Albert with former Canton Police Chief Kenneth Berkowitz, taken at Albert's selectman campaign fundraiser.
Trial 12 mentionsColin Albert knuckle injury photo, Fenway Johnny's (Feb 26, 2022) — Photograph of Colin Albert at Fenway Johnny's on February 26, 2022, showing injured right knuckles.
Trial 12 mentionsCrime Scene Photo Disc — T2 Exhibit 133 — Disc of February 1, 2022 photographs of the Lexus at Canton PD and the 34 Fairview scene, including a bumper image with evidence stickers displayed at trial.
Trial 22 mentionsGlass Fragments on Rear Bumper — T2 Exhibit 141 — Close-up photograph showing apparent glass fragments resting on the rear bumper surface of Karen Read's vehicle, not embedded in it.
Trial 22 mentionsHair on Rear Quarter Panel — T2 Exhibits 144A and 144B — Two photographs documenting an apparent hair found on the rear quarter panel of Karen Read's vehicle, collected as evidence.
Trial 22 mentionsJohn O'Keefe personal photo (T2 Exhibit 16) — Personal photograph of O'Keefe used for identification in Trial 2. Ryan Nagel said he had never seen the depicted person at 34 Fairview.
Trial 22 mentionsKelleher Porch Arlo Camera — Photograph — Photograph of Deputy Chief Kelleher's front porch, with address redacted, showing an Arlo surveillance camera positioned with a potential view of 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 22 mentionsMcLaughlin–Albert swimwear close-up photo — Close-up photograph showing McLaughlin with her arm around Caitlin Albert, both in swimwear. The prosecution noted the photo was cropped from a larger group image.
Trial 12 mentionsO'Keefe Brain Stem — Unredacted Photo (T2 Ex FFF) — Unredacted brain-stem photograph marked FFF for identification. The court required cropping before jury display; the cropped version was admitted as Exhibit 225.
Trial 22 mentionsO'Keefe sneaker near curb — scene photo (T2 Exhibit 74) — Scene photograph showing O'Keefe's sneaker positioned against the curb at 34 Fairview Road, used during Trial 2 with multiple expert witnesses.
Trial 22 mentionsSheridan Expert Review Materials — Autopsy Report and Photos — Autopsy, neuropathology and toxicology reports and photographs reviewed by Sheridan. He agreed with the cause of death but offered competing wound-mechanism and injury-pattern opinions.
Trial 12 mentionsTail Light Damage Photograph — T1 Exhibit 92 — Photograph of Karen Read's Lexus showing damage to the right rear tail light, shown to both Jennifer McCabe and Kerry Roberts during Trial 1.
Trial 12 mentions34 Fairview Rd — additional exterior view (Nicole Albert) — Photograph providing an additional view of the Albert home exterior at 34 Fairview Road, introduced through Nicole Albert.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — D'Antuono vehicle position photo — Photograph of 34 Fairview Road used by Ricky D'Antuono to identify the position of his truck and a parked SUV relative to the property.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — driveway and garage doors — Photograph of 34 Fairview Road showing the driveway and garage doors, depicting the vehicle parking arrangement and proximity of the driveway to the house.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — drone/scale diagrams with evidence markers — Scale diagrams derived from drone imagery of the scene at 34 Fairview Road showing the pedestrian's final rest position, shoe, glass cup, and plastic debris locations with measurements.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — eight exterior photo set (Exhibits 58–65) — A set of eight photographs of 34 Fairview Road exterior showing the house, yard, driveway, property line, fire hydrant, and flagpole area, introduced collectively during Brian Albert's testimony.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — evidence location photo (Exhibit 113/T1) — Photograph or exhibit related to evidence locations at 34 Fairview Road, referenced during O'Hara's testimony but whose display was interrupted by a jury break.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — front exterior, Tedman reference (T2 Exhibit 46) — Photograph of the front of 34 Fairview Road used by defense investigator John Tedman to identify and describe the entrances to the property.
Trial 21 mention34 Fairview Rd — front/side/garage sightline photo (T2 McCabe / Exhibit H) — Photograph of 34 Fairview Road showing the front door, side door, garage door, and flat lawn, used in Trial 2 during Jennifer McCabe's testimony.
Trial 21 mention34 Fairview Rd — garage interior and entrance photos (not admitted / T2) — Photographs of the interior of the garage at 34 Fairview Road showing garage features including hard surfaces and a step, marked for identification only and not admitted into evidence in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mention34 Fairview Rd — graphic representation (Nicole Albert / Exhibit X) — A graphic representation of the exterior of 34 Fairview Road, introduced through Nicole Albert to establish the location of bedroom windows relative to the front lawn.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — house windows and lighting (Levinson) — Photograph showing the windows of the Albert house at 34 Fairview Road, used during Sarah Levinson's testimony in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mention34 Fairview Rd — property boundary near electrical box — Photograph showing the property boundary area near the electrical box and fire hydrant at 34 Fairview Road, depicting the area near the property line with the neighboring house.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — redacted exterior photo set (T2 Exhibit 224) — A redacted version of the previously admitted Exhibit 34 (34 Fairview Road photographs), marked as Exhibit 224 during Trial 2 proceedings without objection from the Commonwealth.
Trial 21 mention34 Fairview Rd — side door and garage entrance — Photograph showing the side door and garage door area of 34 Fairview Road, depicting the side entrance used by most visitors the evening of January 28–29.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — spot where O'Keefe was found (Goode) — Photograph of the area of 34 Fairview Road's lawn where O'Keefe was discovered, used by Sgt. Goode to document the discovery spot.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd — Tedman photo of side front door and garage — Photograph taken by defense investigator John Tedman showing the side front door, garage door, and car doors at 34 Fairview Road, offered to document the property layout as observed by the defense.
Trial 21 mention34 Fairview Rd — two rightmost entrance photo (Tedman) — Photograph showing the two rightmost entrances to 34 Fairview Road — the secondary front door and the red pedestrian garage door — used by defense investigator Tedman.
Trial 21 mention34 Fairview Rd crime scene photo disc — Feb 3 (T2 Exhibit 135) — A disc of crime scene photographs taken by Trooper Brent on February 3, 2022, at 34 Fairview Road and 1 Meadows Road documenting evidence recovery and property conditions.
Trial 21 mention34 Fairview Rd debris photos — Feb 3 search (Exhibits 468–487/T1) — Photographs of the lawn at 34 Fairview Road taken during the secondary search on February 3, 2022, documenting plastic fragments, glass shards, and other debris as found.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd lawn photos post-snow removal (Laposata) — Scene photographs of the 34 Fairview Road lawn after snow removal, used during defense expert Dr. Elizabeth Laposata's testimony in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mention34 Fairview Rd scene diagrams — O'Hara overhead layout (Exhibits 135–136/T1) — Overhead scene diagrams created by Lieutenant O'Hara showing the layout of the roadway and scene at 34 Fairview Road, introduced through Officer Paul.
Trial 11 mention34 Fairview Rd scene photo set — Gallagher (Exhibits 20–32/T1) — Gallagher scene photographs showing snow, blood, broken cocktail glass, the berm, driveway vehicles and the area where O'Keefe was found at 34 Fairview.
Trial 11 mentionAlbert Dog Bite Mark Comparison Photograph — Photos Lally described as a later bite by the Alberts' dog. Sheridan said he did not know about that incident and had not been shown the photographs.
Trial 11 mentionAutopsy — Law Enforcement at Morgue Photo (T2 Ex 163) — A photograph of two law enforcement individuals in the Cape Cod morgue setting during O'Keefe's autopsy, admitted in Trial 2. Dr. Scordi-Bello could not identify the individuals pictured.
Trial 21 mentionChris and Julie Albert straddling O'Keefe's fence (April 2021) — Two photographs of Chris and Julie Albert straddling John O'Keefe's fence with drinks, taken approximately April 2021.
Trial 11 mentionClose-Up Tail Light Area — T2 Exhibit 140 — Close-up photograph of the rear passenger tail light area of Karen Read's vehicle.
Trial 21 mentionColin Albert and Michael Proctor wedding photo — Wedding party photograph showing Colin Albert and Trooper Michael Proctor together at Courtney Proctor's wedding.
Trial 11 mentionDashboard and Backup Warning System Photos — T2 Exhibits 134A–134C — Three photographs of the vehicle's dashboard area showing the odometer reading and the backup warning system display.
Trial 21 mentionFairview Road Google Street View images (northbound/southbound) — Google Street View images of Fairview Road facing northbound and southbound, showing roadway conditions and orientation relative to 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionFairview Road photograph used by Judson Welcher — Fairview Road photograph Welcher used as a demonstrative. Brennan attributed it to the CARS report in a question; Welcher said he did not know its provenance.
Trial 21 mentionFairview Road street view in snow — Photograph showing Fairview Road and the surrounding area blanketed in snow, taken after sunrise rather than at the dark arrival time.
Trial 11 mentionForensic-Literature Reference — Wischnewski Spots — A forensic-literature reference photograph of an opened stomach lining showing Wischnewski ulcers, used in Trial 2 during Dr. Laposata's testimony. It is not a photograph of John O'Keefe.
Trial 21 mentionFranken Truck (Truck 30) — interior and exterior photos (T2 Exs 211A–D) — Four photographs of the Franken Truck (plow truck 30) showing the exterior front view and three interior views depicting visibility from the driver's seat.
Trial 21 mentionGoogle Maps aerial diagram of scene area (Welcher / T2) — A Google Maps or aerial image diagram of the scene area used by Judson Welcher during Trial 2, noted as lacking Trooper Paul's annotations.
Trial 21 mentionGPS-mapped evidence locations at 34 Fairview Rd — GPS-mapped locations of evidence items recovered at 34 Fairview Road, showing that only three of six or seven plastic pieces were mapped.
Trial 11 mentionHillside bar photo: Brian Albert, Chris Albert, O'Keefe (Jan 22, 2022) — Photograph from January 22, 2022, at the Hillside bar showing Brian Albert, Chris Albert, John O'Keefe, and Tim Daly.
Trial 11 mentionIlluminated Tail Light Photographs — 5:07 AM and 4:12 PM (T2) — Photographs of Karen Read's SUV tail lights taken at 5:07 a.m. and 4:12 p.m. showing the tail lights fully illuminated.
Trial 21 mentionJohn O'Keefe with 1971 Ford LTD convertible (T1 victim photo) — Photograph of John O'Keefe with his 1971 Ford LTD convertible, introduced as the opening victim photograph in Trial 1.
Trial 11 mentionKey locations map — Fairview/Waterfall/Canton Library/Meadows — Map with icons showing the locations of significance in the case including 34 Fairview Road, the Waterfall Bar, Canton Library, Temple Beth Abraham, and 1 Meadows Lane, along Washington Street.
Trial 11 mentionLaposata Expert Review — Full Autopsy Photo Collection — 104 autopsy and neuropathology photographs and about 70 additional Watson photographs reviewed by Laposata for her Trial 2 injury analysis.
Trial 21 mentionLaposata Expert Review — Skull, Scalp, and Brain Photos — Autopsy photographs of John O'Keefe's scalp, skull, and brain reviewed by defense expert Dr. Elizabeth Laposata in Trial 2 as the visual basis for her wound pattern analysis and coup-contrecoup determination.
Trial 21 mentionLaposata Review — Police Garage Vehicle Photographs (T2) — Photographs of Karen Read's SUV at the police garage reviewed by Dr. Laposata.
Trial 21 mentionLaposata Review — SUV Exterior Photographs (T2) — Photographs of the exterior of Karen Read's SUV reviewed by Dr. Laposata as part of her case materials.
Trial 21 mentionLoughran plow route map — Trial 1 — Map of Brian Loughran's plow route showing streets including Cedarcrest, Fairview, Chapman, and Spring Lane, admitted into evidence during Trial 1.
Trial 11 mentionMcLaughlin at scene photo with Karen Read (Exhibit 381) — Still photograph showing McLaughlin in her yellow-red fire jacket with Karen Read to her right, a civilian woman to her left, and a police officer diagonally across.
Trial 11 mentionMcLaughlin–Albert baby shower photo (June 2021) — Defense-proffered photo said to show McLaughlin and Albert at a June 2021 baby shower. Later marked S for identification; admission of the photo set as full exhibits was denied.
Trial 11 mentionMcLaughlin–Albert beach group photo (~20–25 people) — Group photograph from social media showing McLaughlin and Caitlin Albert together at a beach with approximately 20 to 25 people.
Trial 11 mentionMcLaughlin–Albert group photo (~12 people, unidentified location) — Group photograph showing McLaughlin and Caitlin Albert with approximately 12 people at an unidentified location.
Trial 11 mentionMcLaughlin–Albert Maine hot tub photo (2016) — Defense-proffered image said to show McLaughlin and Albert in a Maine hot tub, posted or tagged in 2016. The later photo set was marked for identification but denied admission as full exhibits.
Trial 11 mentionNebbercracker sign on O'Keefe's fence — Photographs of a 'Nebbercracker' sign placed on John O'Keefe's fence.
Trial 11 mentionNeighborhood map with red dot at 34 Fairview Rd (Tedman) — Neighborhood map showing Cedarcrest Road, Fairview Road, and Chapman Street with a red dot marking 34 Fairview Road, used by defense investigator John Tedman.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Arm — Russell Voir Dire Autopsy Closeup, Wrist (T1 VD Ex 3) — Wrist-area autopsy close-up used in Russell's Trial 1 voir dire. She attributed an arch of at least four striations to the front teeth of a large dog's jaw.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Arm — Russell Voir Dire Hospital Photo (T1 VD Ex 2) — A hospital photograph of John O'Keefe's arm showing injuries, used during the voir dire examination of Dr. Marie Russell in Trial 1 to assess her qualifications as an expert witness.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Autopsy Face — Front View (T2 Ex 157) — An autopsy photograph of John O'Keefe's face from the front, showing bilateral periorbital discoloration and nasal abrasions, admitted in Trial 2 through Dr. Scordi-Bello's testimony.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Autopsy Face — Right Side View (T2 Ex 156) — An autopsy photograph of John O'Keefe's face from the right side, showing the right eyelid laceration, periorbital hemorrhage, and medical intervention devices, admitted in Trial 2 through Dr. Scordi-Bello's testimony.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Brain Stem — Duret Hemorrhages Cross-Section (T2 Ex 225) — Cropped brain-stem cross-section admitted as Trial 2 Exhibit 225. Laposata used the Duret hemorrhages to explain herniation as the mechanism of death from the head injury.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe ED Room — Clothing and Investigator Photo (T2 Ex 110) — A photograph taken from John O'Keefe's emergency department room, showing his clothing on the hospital floor and an investigator's notepad on a chair, admitted in Trial 2 through Sgt. Bukhenik's testimony.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Face Photo — Post-Autopsy After Cleaning (T1 Ex 65) — A post-autopsy photograph of John O'Keefe's face after cleaning, showing orbital ecchymosis, an eyelid laceration, and nasal abrasions, admitted in Trial 1 through Dr. Scordi-Bello's testimony.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Hospital — Lucas Machine Compression Mark (T2 Ex 228) — A photograph of John O'Keefe at the hospital showing a circular mark on his chest from the Lucas mechanical CPR compression device, admitted in Trial 2 through Dr. Laposata's testimony.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Knee Abrasion Photo (T1 Ex 657) — A photograph of John O'Keefe's knees showing a right-side abrasion, taken from the right side, admitted in Trial 1 on redirect examination of defense expert Dr. Frank Sheridan.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Lower Extremities / Knee Abrasion Photo (T2 Ex 159) — An autopsy photograph of John O'Keefe's lower extremities showing a small lateral right knee abrasion, admitted in Trial 2 through Dr. Scordi-Bello's testimony.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Periorbital Bruising — Raccoon's Eyes (T2 Ex 14) — Trial 2 photograph of bruising around both eyes. Aizik Wolf testified that this indicated a basilar skull fracture and required at least one to three hours to develop.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Posterior Right Arm Abrasion Photo (T1 Ex 442) — Trial 1 photograph of superficial right-arm and forearm abrasions. Scordi-Bello testified that those abrasions did not contribute to the cause of death.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Rib Cage / Lividity Photo (T1 People's Ex 648) — Trial 1 rib-cage photograph. Scordi-Bello clarified on cross that the apparent bruising was postmortem lividity rather than a traumatic injury.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Right Arm — Scene Authentication Photo (T1 Ex 382) — Right-arm photograph authenticated by Woodbury in Trial 1 to confirm the location and extent of scratches he observed on January 29.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Right Arm Laceration Photo (T2 Ex 168) — Trial 2 right-arm laceration photograph used to cross-examine Welcher about the wounds' orientation relative to his horizontal vehicle-contact theory.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Right Hand Contusion Photo (T2 Ex 158) — An autopsy photograph of the back of John O'Keefe's right hand showing two contusions, one of which may be related to IV access, admitted in Trial 2 through Dr. Scordi-Bello's testimony.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Traverse photos — all angles, Feb 3 (T2 Exhibit 136) — Seven photographs of the Chevrolet Traverse and garage doors at 1 Meadows Road taken by Trooper Brent on February 3, 2022, showing the vehicle from all angles and both garage doors.
Trial 21 mentionPhotographs of recovered evidence items in situ — Photographs of recovered evidence items at 34 Fairview Road as they lay when discovered during the search.
Trial 11 mentionPreviously admitted scene photos and videos — T2 Day 4 reference — Reference to previously admitted photographs and videos of the 34 Fairview Road scene, discussed by both attorneys during Trial 2 Day 4 proceedings.
Trial 21 mentionRear of Lexus SUV — General Photo (T2 Exhibit 338) — Photograph of the rear of the black Lexus SUV taken during Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionRear of Lexus SUV with Caution Tape (T1 Exhibit 145) — Photograph of the rear of the black Lexus SUV showing the damage area including bumper scratches and the tail light area, partially obscured by caution tape.
Trial 11 mentionRed dumpster video still across from Fairview Rd (T2 Exhibit 71) — Video still photograph showing a large red dumpster across the street from 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 21 mentionRentschler Expert Review — ME Records and Autopsy Photos — Medical examiner records and autopsy photographs used by Rentschler in Trial 2 to catalogue skull fractures, hemorrhages and arm abrasions.
Trial 21 mentionRight Rear Tail Light with Snow Accumulation — T2 Exhibit 10 — Photograph of the Lexus showing the right rear tail light with a missing portion and snow accumulation on the vehicle.
Trial 21 mentionSallyport Photograph — Lexus License Plate and Tail Light (T2) — Photograph of Karen Read's SUV in the Canton PD sallyport showing the license plate and broken tail light area. A white rag or paper towel is visible on the ground nearby.
Trial 21 mentionSallyport Photograph — Lexus with Grocery Bag (T1) — Photograph of Karen Read's vehicle taken in the Canton PD sallyport. A Stop and Shop grocery bag is visible near the vehicle.
Trial 11 mentionScene and vehicle photographs reviewed by Dr. Sheridan — Scene photographs and vehicle photographs, including photos from Good Samaritan Hospital and the scene of death, reviewed by defense expert Dr. Frank Sheridan as part of his case analysis.
Trial 11 mentionScene debris field photos reviewed by Dr. Wolfe (T1) — 34 Fairview debris-field photographs reviewed by Wolfe in Trial 1, showing plastic, chrome, glass and a black drinking straw on the lawn.
Trial 11 mentionScene photographs reviewed by Dr. Scordi-Bello — Scene photographs of where O'Keefe's body was found, reviewed by medical examiner Dr. Scordi-Bello as part of her analysis.
Trial 11 mentionSet of Five Autopsy and Hospital Photos (T1 Ex 64) — Five hospital and autopsy photographs admitted through Scordi-Bello in Trial 1, depicting arm, hand, eye-area, nose and back-of-head injuries.
Trial 11 mentionShovel imprint near red taillight piece (T2 Exhibit 75A) — Close-up photograph showing a shovel imprint in the snow adjacent to a red taillight piece recovered at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 21 mentionTail Light Damage Photographs — McCabe (T1, no exhibit) — Photographs of Karen Read's Lexus showing rear passenger side tail light damage, shown to Jennifer McCabe during Trial 1 before formal exhibit introduction.
Trial 11 mentionTail Light Fins Photograph — T2 Exhibit 41 — Photograph of the Lexus tail light showing protruding fins on the quarter panel.
Trial 21 mentionThree-Page Vehicle Damage Diagram (T1 Exhibit 137) — A three-page vehicle diagram used by the trooper to document the location of damage, hair, and glass fragments on the Lexus SUV.
Trial 11 mentionTristin Morris at Ned Devine's with Albert/McCabe family — Photograph from Ned Devine's bar in Boston showing Tristin Morris with eleven members of the Albert and McCabe families, posted to social media by Kevin Reon on June 5, 2022.
Trial 11 mentionVehicle Precipitation Photo/Video — January 29, 2022 (T2 Exhibit 124) — January 29 image of unidentified white material falling from the rear of Read's vehicle. Hartnett said she did not know when the apparent glass appeared on the bumper.
Trial 21 mentionVideo Stills of Tail Light Damage — T1 Exhibits 101 and 102 — Still images extracted from video showing Read's vehicle and a close-up of the tail light damage.
Trial 11 mentionYannetti photo in DiCicco–Proctor group chat — Photograph of defense attorney Yannetti sent by Trooper DiCicco in a group chat, which prompted a derogatory response from Trooper Proctor about Read and Yannetti.
Trial 11 mentionVideo Evidence (57)
Waterfall Bar & Grille Surveillance Video, Jan. 28–29, 2022 — Waterfall Bar security footage from January 28–29, 2022, showing the interior, lobby and parking lot and the movements of Read, O'Keefe, Jennifer McCabe and the Albert–Higgins group.
Trial 1Trial 221 mentionsRing Video 153 — Lexus Departs Carport, 5:07 AM — 5:07 a.m. Ring footage of the Lexus reversing near O'Keefe's Traverse, with taillight-area damage visible. Aperture analyzed possible contact; replacement of the original camera was questioned on cross.
Trial 1Trial 217 mentionsCruiser 683 Dashcam — Saraf, 34 Fairview Scene — Cruiser 683 footage from 34 Fairview on January 29, 2022, showing blizzard conditions, people around O'Keefe, scene tape and Read's damaged taillight.
Trial 1Trial 216 mentionsCanton PD Sallyport Interior Video, Jan 29, 2022 — Canton PD sallyport video of the Lexus's arrival and Proctor near its right rear. The original was mirror-inverted; the defense later introduced a corrected version.
Trial 1Trial 211 mentionsC.F. McCarthy's Bar Surveillance Video, Jan. 28, 2022 — Interior surveillance footage from C.F. McCarthy's bar from January 28, 2022. The video depicts Karen Read, John O'Keefe, and others at the bar, including their interactions and Read departing with a glass in her hand.
Trial 1Trial 27 mentionsCruiser 682 Dashcam — Goode/Rae, Fairview & Meadows Ave. — Cruiser 682 footage showing the Fairview scene and snow on the lawn, plus an approximately 8:23 a.m. well-being check at 1 Meadows Avenue and Read's vehicle there.
Trial 1Trial 26 mentionsRing Footage — McCabe, Roberts & Read Search O'Keefe's Home — Ring footage of Read, McCabe and Roberts arriving at O'Keefe's home to search. Trial 2 clip 12C showed all three entering without stopping at Read's vehicle.
Trial 1Trial 26 mentionsDighton Residence — Lexus Tow and Taillight Documentation — Dighton video of the Lexus being towed around 4:15 p.m. on January 29. A still shows a red lens portion remaining attached to the taillight during towing.
Trial 1Trial 25 mentionsCanton Public Library Surveillance — Washington St. Intersection — Motion-activated library footage of Washington and Sherman Streets during midnight–1 a.m. and 5–6 a.m. on January 29, automatically deleted before defense access.
Trial 14 mentionsColin Albert Threatening Video — 'Advantage' Confrontation — Videos of Colin Albert making threats. He and the prosecution described mutual exchanges when he was about 16, with no physical contact alleged to have followed.
Trial 13 mentionsFlematti Scene Dashcam — Split-Screen, T1 Exhibit 379 — Dashcam video from a police cruiser at 34 Fairview Road showing the scene with a split-screen top and bottom camera view. Played during the testimony of EMT Anthony Flematti in Trial 1.
Trial 13 mentionsSynchronized Saraf+Goode Dashcam — T1 Exhibit 16 — Side-by-side synchronized dashcam video combining footage from Officer Saraf's cruiser and Sergeant Goode's Cruiser 682 at 34 Fairview Road on January 29, 2022.
Trial 13 mentions34 Fairview Road Scene Body Cam / Surveillance (T2 Exhibit 4) — Video footage, either body camera or fixed surveillance, from the scene at 34 Fairview Road on January 29, 2022, capturing interactions among first responders and bystanders including Read and McCabe.
Trial 22 mentionsCanton PD Exterior Surveillance, Jan 29, 2022 — Higgins 1:27–1:45 AM — Four Canton PD surveillance views showing Higgins arriving in his Jeep, entering, using a phone and accessing vehicles before leaving around 1:45 a.m. on January 29.
Trial 22 mentionsCanton PD Opposite Sallyport Camera — 5:07–5:50 p.m. Gap — Sallyport video with a 5:07–5:50 p.m. timestamp gap of about 43 minutes 37 seconds, spanning time before and after the SUV arrived. Testimony did not establish why the interval was missing.
Trial 22 mentionsCanton PD Sallyport Video, Feb 1, 2022 (Search Warrant Execution) — Canton PD sallyport surveillance recording from February 1, 2022, capturing the State Police execution of a search warrant on Read's vehicle, including the removal of the taillight by Officer Wanless.
Trial 12 mentionsColin Albert Threatening Video — 'Bang Bang / KO' — Video of Colin Albert making violent threats including the phrases 'pull up,' 'KO,' and 'bang bang,' sent to a club hockey team.
Trial 12 mentionsDashcam Still Photo — Driveway/Lexus, T2 Exhibit 10 — Still photograph extracted from cruiser dashcam video showing the driveway at 1 Meadows Ave. at approximately 8:03 a.m. on January 29, 2022, with Karen Read's Lexus visible.
Trial 22 mentionsDriving Conditions Route to Fairview Road (T1 Exhibit 12) — Video showing the driving route to 34 Fairview Road on January 29, 2022, depicting snow, darkness, and poor visibility during the early morning hours.
Trial 12 mentionsKaren Read Interview — Clip Three — Read interview 'clip three,' played during proceedings involving Kerry Roberts. Its content was not fully captured in the available transcripts; prosecutors reviewed it before showing it.
Trial 22 mentionsLeaf Blower Scene Excavation Videos (T2 Exhibit 51) — Two videos of Lt. Gallagher directing the use of a leaf blower to excavate snow at the scene at 34 Fairview Road, memorialized at Gallagher's direction.
Trial 22 mentionsRing Footage — Officers Rae & Lank Arrive at One Meadows — Ring doorbell footage from One Meadows Avenue showing Lt. Rae and Sgt. Lank exiting their cruiser, approaching the O'Keefe residence, and attempting to raise the occupants.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsWaterfall Surveillance Still: O'Keefe Holding Glass with Straw — A still photograph extracted from Waterfall Bar & Grille surveillance footage showing John O'Keefe holding a drinking glass with a black straw.
Trial 22 mentions34 Fairview Basement Bulkhead to Front Yard Walkthrough — Video walkthrough tracing the path from the 34 Fairview Road basement through the bulkhead door and gate to the front lawn.
Trial 11 mentionAdmitted Ring Video of Read's Lexus Near or Contacting O'Keefe's Vehicle — Admitted Ring video of the Lexus backing near or contacting O'Keefe's vehicle. Courtroom magnification was live display enlargement, not an enhancement embedded in the video.
Trial 11 mentionAlarm.com Dighton Arrival Footage — 2:12 p.m. and 4:12 p.m. — Alarm.com footage at the Dighton residence at 2:12 and 4:12 p.m. on January 29, including vehicle arrival, wipers stopping and suspension lowering at 2:12:01.
Trial 21 mentionARCCA Expert Communication Hearing Clips — Video clips from a prior day's hearing provided by ADA Brennan, relating to communications between defense ARCCA experts.
Trial 21 mentionBar Surveillance PowerPoint Compilation (McCarthy's and Waterfall) — A PowerPoint presentation on CD compiling chronological bar surveillance footage from both C.F. McCarthy's and the Waterfall.
Trial 21 mentionBrennan's Reference to January 28 Ring Videos of Read's Car — Brennan asked Hartnett whether she knew of January 28, 2022 Ring videos of Read's car. Hartnett said she did not know of them; their location, contents, and admission were not established through her testimony.
Trial 21 mentionCanton PD Driveway Video — Tow Truck and Bukhenik Arrival — Canton PD driveway surveillance depicting the arrival of a tow truck followed by Bukhenik's pickup truck.
Trial 21 mentionCanton PD Exterior Sallyport Video — Tow Truck with Read's Lexus — Canton PD exterior sallyport surveillance showing the tow truck arriving with Read's Lexus SUV.
Trial 21 mentionCanton PD Sallyport Footage — Lexus with Snow, Jan 29, 5:51 PM — Video footage showing Read's Lexus SUV with snow and ice on the right rear area, timestamped 5:51:54 PM on January 29, 2022.
Trial 21 mentionCanton PD Sallyport Front Wall Video, Jan 29, 2022 — Canton PD sallyport footage from the front wall camera for January 29, 2022. The original recording was dark; an enhanced version was subsequently produced and played for the jury.
Trial 21 mentionCanton PD Sallyport Still Photo, Jan 30, 2022 at 11:08 AM — A still photograph from the opposite sallyport camera showing Read's SUV, an antique police cruiser, and an unidentified person, timestamped approximately 11:08 a.m. on January 30, 2022.
Trial 21 mentionCanton PD Sallyport Video, Jan 1, 2022 (Pre-Incident Inversion Proof) — Canton PD sallyport surveillance recording from January 1, 2022, predating the incident by 28 days.
Trial 21 mentionCanton PD Vehicle Testing Videos — Acceleration and Visibility — Videos recording exterior and interior testing of Read's vehicle at Canton PD, memorializing acceleration and braking tests and a visibility analysis of functional backup cameras and proximity sensors.
Trial 11 mentionCanton PD Video — Right Rear Taillight Damage at 8:22 AM — Video footage documenting visible damage to Read's right rear taillight, timestamped 8:22 a.m.
Trial 11 mentionDashcam Still Photo — Closeup, T2 Exhibit 11 — Closeup still photograph extracted from Cruiser 682's dashcam video showing the vehicle in the driveway at 1 Meadows Ave. during the 8:23 a.m. well-being check.
Trial 21 mentionKaren Read Interview — Clip 4 — Read interview clip describing her presumption that O'Keefe's mother saw the cracked taillight, her discomfort and her belief that his mother thought she had done something to him.
Trial 21 mentionKaren Read Interview — Clip 5 — Video clip of Karen Read stating that Peggy O'Keefe told her John looked like he was hit by a car.
Trial 21 mentionKaren Read Interview — Clips 12 and 12A — Read interview clips 12 and 12A, which Brennan expected to play after McCabe to establish a basis for testimony about directions referencing Bella's mother's house.
Trial 21 mentionKaren Read Interview — Clips 7 through 11 — A series of video clips (numbered 7 through 11) from Karen Read's interviews covering her statements about her alcohol consumption and driving ability on the night of January 28–29, 2022.
Trial 21 mentionKaren Read Post-Charge Media Statements — Nightline / Documentary — Footage from post-charge media appearances by Karen Read, including Nightline and documentary recordings, in which Read speculates she could have 'clipped' or 'tagged' O'Keefe.
Trial 21 mentionLeaf Blower Scene Excavation Photos/Video (T1 Exhibit 33) — Video or photographs of Lt. Gallagher using the leaf blower at the scene, documenting the snow clearing that revealed blood droplets and a broken drinking glass where O'Keefe was found.
Trial 11 mentionLeaf Blower Scene Excavation Video (T1 Exhibit 30) — Video of Lt. Gallagher using a leaf blower to remove snow layer by layer at the scene where O'Keefe was found, revealing frozen blood and a cocktail glass beneath.
Trial 11 mentionRing Footage — Camerano & O'Keefe Move Cars, Jan. 28 Eve. — January 28 Ring footage of Camerano and O'Keefe moving vehicles at 1 Meadows Avenue, including clip 148 showing O'Keefe moving his car so Read could enter the garage.
Trial 11 mentionRing Footage — Driveway With Both Vehicles (Exhibit 41) — Ring camera video shown during Jennifer McCabe's testimony depicting O'Keefe's driveway with both O'Keefe's vehicle and Read's Lexus visible, including a view of the taillight area of Read's vehicle.
Trial 11 mentionRing Footage — Lt. Rae Exits O'Keefe Residence — Ring doorbell clip from One Meadows Avenue showing Lt. Rae exiting the front of the O'Keefe residence and walking across the driveway.
Trial 11 mentionRing Footage — Paul O'Keefe's Jan. 29 Arrival Sequence — January 29 Ring footage of Paul O'Keefe's arrival, Read arriving with Nathan Read, Patrick's drop-off, Read leaving with belongings, snow removal and Paul leaving.
Trial 11 mentionRing Footage — Vehicles on Fairview Road, Night Jan. 28–29 — Ring camera footage from the night of January 28–29, 2022, showing vehicles passing on Fairview Road.
Trial 21 mentionRoad and Weather Conditions Video (T1 Exhibit 25) — Video or image depicting road and weather conditions during the emergency response to Fairview Road on January 29, 2022.
Trial 11 mentionScene Clip — Kelly Cross/Redirect: Ambulance Not Visible — A scene video clip played at the end of Matthew Kelly's cross-examination and then addressed by Lally on redirect; Kelly's ambulance was not visible in the frame.
Trial 11 mentionScene Clip — Kelly Testimony: 'Fucking Dead' Audio — A 15-second video clip with audio from the scene at 34 Fairview Road, played twice during Matthew Kelly's cross-examination.
Trial 11 mentionSynchronized Saraf+Goode Dashcam — T1 Exhibit 26 — Saraf's dashcam video synchronized with Sergeant Goode's dashcam, introduced as a separate exhibit during Saraf's testimony in Trial 1.
Trial 11 mentionTemple Beth Abraham Surveillance — Washington St. — Surveillance video from Temple Beth Abraham showing Washington Street northbound at 12:27 a.m. and at 5:18 a.m. on January 29, 2022.
Trial 11 mentionThree Canton PD Vehicles Dashcam — T2 Gallagher — Dashcam footage from three Canton PD vehicles, referenced during the testimony of Paul Gallagher in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionVideo Clip One — Individual Discussing Contact with Victim — Read interview 'clip one': she said she did not think she hit anything and asked whether she could have knocked O'Keefe out, with cold and intoxication preventing recovery.
Trial 21 mentionDigital Evidence (79)
Toyota Lexus TechStream / VCH Event Data — Lexus vehicle-control and TechStream data recording speed, shifting, steering and acceleration. A disputed infotainment timestamp was amended to 12:32:16.
Trial 1Trial 214 mentionsO'Keefe iPhone Apple Health Step and Movement Records — Estimated step intervals around 12:21–12:24 and 12:31:56–12:32:16, then nearly six hours without further Health activity. Hyde said phone motion does not prove who carried it or what caused the motion.
Trial 1Trial 29 mentionsWelcher Aperture PowerPoint Presentation (Ex. 188) — Welcher's 141-slide presentation covering TechStream, photogrammetry, inspections and biomechanics, including his original placement of event 11622 at 12:31:38–12:31:43 on the Lexus clock.
Trial 27 mentionsLexus Airbag Control Module (CDR) Download — Crash data retrieval report downloaded from the airbag control module of Karen Read's 2021 Lexus LX570. The CDR showed zero recorded collision events in the vehicle's history, including on January 29, 2022.
Trial 1Trial 26 mentionsO'Keefe iPhone Battery Temperature Data — O'Keefe's overnight battery-temperature readings, presented through Whiffin's slides, showing cooling from about 82°F at 12:13 a.m. and warming when handled by responders around 6 a.m.
Trial 25 mentionsMcCabe 'How Long to Die in Cold' Google Search — BrowserState record bearing a 2:27:40 a.m. timestamp. The defense read it as a 2:27 search; prosecution experts said the search was at 6:23–6:24 and the earlier value reflected tab state. Timing remained disputed.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsO'Keefe iPhone GPS Location Records (cache.sqlite) — GPS records with accuracy limits. Whiffin opined the phone stayed near the flagpole; identical coordinates and changing accuracy did not independently prove physical immobility.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsO'Keefe iPhone Waze GPS and Clock Comparison Data — Waze GPS, speed and heading data used to compare phone and Lexus clocks, yielding an estimated 21–29-second variance, plus a phone monotonic/display-clock discrepancy.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsJennifer McCabe phone — Cellebrite extraction report — Cellebrite extraction of Jennifer McCabe's phone, documenting calls, deleted data and web-search artifacts, including a 2:27 a.m. timestamp produced by the Commonwealth's tool.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsJennifer McCabe phone — GrayKey forensic image — GrayKey full-file-system image and PDF report from Jennifer McCabe's phone, transmitted to the Norfolk DA and received by the analyzing expert through U.S. mail.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsMcCabe Phone BrowserState.db and WAL File — McCabe's BrowserState database and WAL, including deleted record 4028 with the cold-search URL and a 2:27:40 a.m. timestamp, plus visualizations of live tabs and deleted-record gaps.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsO'Keefe Phone Last Interactive Events — Whiffin Timeline Slide — Whiffin's slide 82: Face ID at 12:32:04, lock at 12:32:09, Health steps at 12:32:16 and pocket state at 12:33:14 a.m., admitted as Trial 2 Exhibit 39.
Trial 23 mentionsPaul CARS Report — VCH Key Cycle Table (Ex. 591) — Paul's vehicle-control history table showing triggering events at miles 12,665–12,666 and 12,629. It lists only key cycles tied to triggers, not the complete key-cycle history.
Trial 13 mentionsSD Card from Lexus Infotainment Module — SD card recovered by Shanon Burgess from the Lexus infotainment module, containing power events, contacts, call logs, device identifiers and location data; not identified in the initial chip-off process.
Trial 23 mentionsVerizon RTT and Call Detail Records — Karen Read's Phone — Verizon range-to-tower and call records admitted in Trial 1, including a 5:18 a.m. entry with a 0.004-second procedure duration and 0.15-mile distance difference.
Trial 13 mentionsAllison McCabe Life360 Location Data — January 29, 2022 — Allison McCabe's disputed Life360 entries. The defense suggested repeated school trips; she denied or could not recall them, and redirect questioned timestamp accuracy through Wi-Fi notices.
Trial 12 mentionsCellebrite release notes — 2:27 AM timestamp artifact removed — Cellebrite software release notes documenting the removal of the parsing artifact that had produced the 2:27 AM search timestamp from McCabe's phone data.
Trial 22 mentionsCellHawk Analysis of O'Keefe Phone Location (Green, Trial 1) — Green's Trial 1 CellHawk analysis of O'Keefe's location data, requested by Yannetti. A screenshot showed zero results when filtered to three-foot accuracy.
Trial 12 mentionsHyde Report — Table 1 (Search Terms Timeline) — Table 1 of Hyde's report, arranging McCabe's two search terms, timestamps and sources chronologically across BrowserState, KnowledgeC, Safari plist and cache artifacts.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsJennifer McCabe iPhone Forensic Extraction — Cellebrite extraction of McCabe's iPhone, including Safari history.db and BrowserState.db artifacts used by prosecution and defense forensic experts.
Trial 12 mentionsJohn O'Keefe phone — GrayKey forensic extraction — GrayKey forensic extraction of John O'Keefe's iPhone 11, producing a full 125 GB file system image. A GrayKey progress report documented the extraction with SHA-256 and MD5 hash values confirming data integrity.
Trial 22 mentionsKaren Read CSLI Maps — Cell Tower Connection Visualizations — Maps of Read's phone connections to cell-tower antennas from about 12:33 to 6:57 a.m., including tower 5721 relative to 34 Fairview and 12 Country Lane.
Trial 12 mentionsMcCabe phone — 'how long to die in cold' Google searches — Cellebrite forensic extraction page from McCabe's phone showing three instances of the Google search 'how long to die in cold': one timestamped 2:27 AM (marked as deleted in the database) and two at 6:23 AM and 6:24 AM.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsMcCabe Phone KnowledgeC.db Web Usage Records — McCabe KnowledgeC records attributing 2:27 a.m. web activity to sports and shopping sites, with the cold search first appearing on screen at 6:23:56 a.m.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsAllison McCabe iPhone — photo app images — Photos from Allison McCabe's iPhone photo application.
Trial 11 mentionARTX Tool Reports — BrowserState Records 4026–4030 — ARTX reports for BrowserState records 4026–4030, comparing their timestamps with history.db entries for browsing activity across late January.
Trial 11 mentionBrian Albert cell phone — number ending 0888 — Brian Albert's cell phone with a number ending in 0888.
Trial 11 mentionBrian Higgins phone — Cellebrite extraction — Cellebrite extraction printout and CD from Brian Higgins's phone, containing text messages and call records involving O'Keefe and Read.
Trial 11 mentionBurgess Call-Log Clock Variance Chart (Ex. 189) — A chart from Burgess's January 30, 2025 report comparing call log timestamps between the Lexus infotainment system and O'Keefe's iPhone, showing clock variance offsets of 1–21 seconds.
Trial 21 mentionBurgess Initial Lexus Infotainment Forensic Report — Shanon Burgess's January 30, 2025 report presenting his initial forensic analysis of the Lexus infotainment data and clock variance calculations.
Trial 21 mentionBurgess Updated Report on Lexus Infotainment Clock Drift — An updated report by Shanon Burgess addressing clock drift in the Lexus infotainment system, produced after his January 30, 2025 initial report.
Trial 21 mentionCell Phone Data Points — Exhibits 192A and 192B — Exhibits 192A and 192B shown to Judson Welcher, containing cell phone data points used to establish timing correlation between Techstream data and O'Keefe's cell phone records.
Trial 21 mentionCellebrite hash verification mechanism — Cellebrite's built-in hash verification mechanism designed to detect post-extraction alterations to extracted phone data.
Trial 11 mentionCellebrite native location maps — O'Keefe phone — Location map data natively generated by Cellebrite analysis of phone data, showing a travel route and stationary position.
Trial 11 mentionCellebrite phone extractions — multi-phone overview — Cellebrite forensic extractions were performed on multiple phones, yielding text messages, call records, and web search history.
Trial 11 mentionCellebrite Physical Analyzer vs. Insights — version comparison — Comparison of two current Cellebrite software versions — Physical Analyzer and Insights — applied to the same search data from McCabe's phone.
Trial 11 mentionCellebrite Release Notes — 2:27 Timestamp Removal — Cellebrite software release notes documenting the removal of the 2:27:40 a.m. timestamp from the tool's extraction output, citing 'further research' as the basis without elaborating on what that research entailed.
Trial 21 mentionCellebrite versions 7.53 vs. 7.61 — McCabe search artifact — Comparison of Cellebrite software versions 7.53 and 7.61 in the context of parsing search data from McCabe's phone.
Trial 11 mentionCrime Scene Handheld GPS Evidence Location Coordinates — GPS coordinate data collected at the crime scene using a handheld GPS device to geo-mark the location of physical evidence items, referenced during Lt. Kevin O'Hara's Trial 2 testimony.
Trial 21 mentionDefense Cell Tower Map — Exhibit 5 (Trial 1) — A defense-created exhibit showing a cell tower map with ranging arcs, marked as Exhibit 5 in Trial 1, used during cross-examination of Lt. Brian Tully.
Trial 11 mentionDeleted call record 623 — McCabe to 'Uncle Brian A' — Cellebrite report entry showing deleted call record 623 from Jennifer McCabe's phone to a contact identified as 'Uncle Brian A,' placed during the early morning hours of January 29, 2022.
Trial 11 mentionDiSogra Three-Point Turn Timestamp Breakdown (Ex. 192A) — A detailed breakdown of three-point turn timestamp 154 data presented by defense expert Matthew DiSogra.
Trial 21 mentionDogra 'All Possible Combinations' Chart (Ex. 190) — A one-page chart from a March 5, 2025 presentation by Dogra titled 'All Possible Combinations,' showing that under every call-log variance calculation method, TechStream event 11622 occurs before the phone lock event.
Trial 21 mentionDr. Russell's Review of Lexus Telematics Data — The telematics (black box) data from Karen Read's vehicle, reviewed by defense expert Dr. Marie Russell as part of her forensic analysis.
Trial 21 mentionGoogle Search URL Parameters from BrowserState Record — Analysis of the Google search URL found in the BrowserState.db record, identifying the 'client=Safari' parameter within the URL string.
Trial 11 mentionGuarino consolidated PowerPoint — texts and calls — Consolidated PowerPoint presentation of text messages and phone calls derived from Trooper Guarino's phone extraction analysis, reorganized into chronological order combining texts and calls.
Trial 21 mentionGuarino Reports on O'Keefe Phone Location and Health Data — Guarino's April 24 and May 9, 2023 reports on O'Keefe's phone location and Health data, accompanied by Google Earth and TRACK maps of the route to 34 Fairview and GPS accuracy circles.
Trial 11 mentionHyde Report — Figure 1 (Sanderson Tool WAL Screenshot) — Figure 1 from Jessica Hyde's forensic report, a screen capture from the Sanderson forensics tool showing approximately 16 entries in the browser_state.db WAL file for 'how long to die in cold,' all sharing the same UUID.
Trial 11 mentionHyde Report — Table 2 (Safari Artifact Reference Guide) — Table 2 from Jessica Hyde's forensic report, explaining what data each Safari artifact stores — private vs. non-private searches, open vs. closed tabs, and what the associated timestamps represent.
Trial 11 mentionIan Whiffin's Reports (Referenced During Green's Testimony) — Ian Whiffin's forensic reports on McCabe phone Google searches, cited during Richard Green's defense expert testimony. Whiffin is also the creator of the ARTX tool that Green used in his own analysis.
Trial 11 mentionJennifer McCabe GPS Location Records — January 29–30, 2022 — Ten-page McCabe GPS document for January 29–30, marked for identification in Trial 2. She said her memory differed from the listed locations and some details were foggy.
Trial 21 mentionJennifer McCabe Health Watch Heart Rate Data — Heart rate data from Jennifer McCabe's health watch, recorded from midnight through the morning of January 29, 2022, noted in Trial 2 proceedings as potential rebuttal evidence. The data cited is from 2023.
Trial 21 mentionJessica Hyde's Report (Referenced During Green's Testimony) — Jessica Hyde's complete forensic report on McCabe phone Google searches, cited during Richard Green's defense expert testimony as a counterpoint to Green's conclusions.
Trial 11 mentionJohn O'Keefe phone — Cellebrite extraction report — Cellebrite forensic extraction report from John O'Keefe's cell phone, documenting call records including calls between O'Keefe and Jennifer McCabe from 12:14 to 12:50 AM.
Trial 11 mentionJohn O'Keefe phone — forensic analysis PowerPoint — PowerPoint presentation summarizing forensic analysis of John O'Keefe's cell phone, covering location data, health data, battery temperature, device usage, and Doppler pocket state.
Trial 21 mentionKaren Read phone — deleted search history, Jan. 29 afternoon — Deleted web search history and cookies from Karen Read's phone from the afternoon of January 29, 2022, the day O'Keefe's body was found.
Trial 11 mentionKaren Read phone — GrayKey full extraction (109 GB) — GrayKey result summary documenting the complete extraction of Karen Read's phone after brute-force passcode recovery, yielding approximately 109 GB of data with hash values distinct from the partial extraction.
Trial 21 mentionKaren Read phone — GrayKey partial extraction (45 GB) — GrayKey result summary documenting the initial partial extraction of Karen Read's phone, yielding approximately 45 GB of data before her passcode was obtained.
Trial 21 mentionLexus Infotainment Module Hardware (Chip-Off Extraction) — Karen Read's Lexus LX570 infotainment system hardware, subjected to a destructive chip-off forensic extraction process over nearly two years.
Trial 11 mentionLive iPhone iOS 15.2.1 — ARTX forensic tool demonstration — A live iPhone running iOS 15.2.1 connected to the ARTX forensic tool, used for a real-time courtroom demonstration of Safari BrowserState timestamp behavior.
Trial 21 mentionMagnet AXIOM artifact reference guide — Reference guide for forensic artifacts in Magnet AXIOM software.
Trial 21 mentionMagnet AXIOM Output — 2:27 Timestamp — Output from the Magnet AXIOM forensic tool showing the 2:27:40 a.m. timestamp still recovered and displayed from McCabe's phone data, even after Cellebrite removed the timestamp from its own extraction output.
Trial 21 mentionMagnet AXIOM Screenshot — 'It's Raining Men' Comparison — Magnet AXIOM screenshot of 'It's Raining Men' search history, used by Green as a comparison to explain Safari suspended-tab timestamps.
Trial 11 mentionMcCabe Phone Google Search Records — Guarino Testimony — McCabe search records with 6:23:51 and 2:27:40 values. Guarino said the searches occurred at 6:23–6:24 and that WAL deletion marks can reflect automated cleanup rather than user action.
Trial 11 mentionMobile Safari Plist vs. History.db Comparison Table — Comparison table showing the cold searches in Mobile Safari plist but not history.db, unlike other searches appearing in both databases within seconds.
Trial 11 mentionNicole Albert phone — Cellebrite extraction report — Cellebrite forensic extraction report from Nicole Albert's cell phone.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe iPhone Digital Evidence — Prosecution Overview — Overview of O'Keefe phone evidence used for the prosecution's Trial 2 timeline, including Waze locations, Health movement data and battery temperatures.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe iPhone Unified Logs — Call Log Rotation Records — Records from the unified logs on O'Keefe's iPhone, analyzed by Jessica Hyde in Trial 2, showing the mechanism by which call log entries were deleted as the log reached its capacity limit.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe iPhone Unified Logs — Pocket State Records — O'Keefe iPhone unified-log Doppler and pocket-state records, including about 26,500 consecutive checks over more than five hours indicating a continuously blocked camera.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe phone — power log file, three-clock timestamps — Power log file from John O'Keefe's phone containing three different timestamp values (monotonic, baseband, and display clocks), introduced as a defense exhibit.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe phone — Process 3434, three-clock discrepancy printout — Printout from John O'Keefe's phone showing Process 3434, depicting three different internal iPhone clocks — monotonic, baseband, and display — that were not synchronized with one another.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Phone KnowledgeC Battery Temperature Records — O'Keefe battery-temperature records: Whiffin described a fall from 82°F to 50°F by 1:36 a.m., a recording gap until 43°F at 6:06, a low of 37°F at 6:14, then warming.
Trial 21 mentionPaul CARS Report — Trigger 12629-A Chart (Ex. 593) — A vehicle control history data chart from Paul's CARS report for triggering event 12,629-A, showing the vehicle slowing and making a U-turn through a drive-to-reverse-to-drive sequence.
Trial 11 mentionPaul CARS Report — Trigger 12629-B Chart (Ex. 594) — Paul's chart for trigger 12,629-B, showing a stop from drive, a shift into reverse and acceleration to 24.2 mph at 74.5% throttle in a near-straight line.
Trial 11 mentionPaul CARS Report — Trigger 12629-B Distance Chart (Ex. 596) — A distance chart calculated from the 12,629-B VCH data in Paul's CARS report, showing the vehicle traveled 62.5 feet before reaching 24.2 mph and 97.35 feet total during the reverse acceleration event.
Trial 11 mentionProsecution Antenna Arc Ranging Maps (Exhibit 576) — Maps showing antenna ranging arcs for Karen Read's phone at two time points — 12:17 a.m. and 5:18 a.m. — admitted as Exhibit 576 in Trial 1 during Lt. Tully's testimony.
Trial 11 mentionSpecialist reports on McCabe phone — Gino, Hyde, Whiffin — Collection of reports from Trooper Nicholas Gino, Jessica Hyde, and Ian Whiffin concerning Cellebrite forensic analysis of Jennifer McCabe's phone.
Trial 11 mentionTrooper Location Data — Exhibit ZZ — A document, admitted as Exhibit ZZ in Trial 2, containing location data from testimony attributed to Trooper Gino, reviewed during Shanon Burgess's cross-examination.
Trial 21 mentionWhiffin T2 PowerPoint — Browser State Analysis — A PowerPoint presentation prepared by Ian Whiffin for Trial 2, walking the jury through tab-focus timestamp behavior and the distinction between the 2:27 a.m. and 6:24 a.m. search timings on McCabe's phone.
Trial 21 mentionDocumentary Evidence (232)
Scordi-Bello Autopsy Report for John O'Keefe — Scordi-Bello's autopsy report, with injury diagrams, skull-fracture findings, bruising around the eyes and right-arm abrasions, reviewed by experts from both sides.
Trial 1Trial 213 mentionsKaren Read Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Records (93 mg/dL BAC) — Read's January 29 Good Samaritan records, including Section 12 admission documents and a hospital serum-ethanol result of 93 mg/dL from a 9:08 a.m. sample.
Trial 1Trial 212 mentionsProctor High School Friend Group Chat — Proctor's roughly 38,777-message chat with childhood friends, including investigative details, early conclusions about Read and a message wishing she would kill herself.
Trial 1Trial 212 mentionsFeb 1, 2022 Albert–McCabe Family Group Chat — Albert–McCabe family texts beginning February 1, including instructions to say O'Keefe never entered the house, monitoring of Kerry Roberts's interview and requests for updates.
Trial 1Trial 210 mentionsColin Albert–Allie McCabe Texts (Jan 28–29, 2022) — Colin Albert–Allie McCabe ride-request screenshots, produced 18 months later from a replacement phone without a Cellebrite extraction. The defense argued the timestamps could be altered manually.
Trial 19 mentionsHiggins–Read Texts (Jan 12–29, 2022) — A 118-page Higgins–Read text chain from January 12–29, covering romantic interest, Read's relationship complaints, a communication gap and Higgins's final message, 'John died.'
Trial 1Trial 27 mentionsO'Keefe Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Records — O'Keefe's January 29 Good Samaritan records, including Rice's emergency note and discharge chart, the code sheet, examination records, an 80.1°F temperature and photographs.
Trial 1Trial 27 mentionsBrian Higgins Phone Records — Jan 29 (incl. 2:22 AM Call) — Higgins's January 29 call records, including a one-second missed call from Brian Albert at 2:22 a.m., a 22-second return call and later calls among Higgins, the Alberts and Berkowitz.
Trial 1Trial 25 mentionsEvidence Submission Form / Chain of Custody (March 14, 2022) — Submission forms and a crime-lab custody log documenting Proctor's March 14, 2022 delivery of clothing, plastic, glass and a cocktail straw to the lab.
Trial 1Trial 25 mentionsCanton Animal Control Records — Chloe's Bite History — Canton animal control records, reports, and photographs documenting the bite history of the German Shepherd Chloe, the dog at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 14 mentionsDe Munnich et al. — 'Forensic Approach of Fatal Dog Attacks' — Peer-reviewed study by De Munnich et al. published in the International Journal of Legal Medicine, examining forensic aspects of fatal dog attacks including parallel claw marks and puncture wound patterns.
Trial 24 mentionsFlematti EMS Patient Care Report — Flematti's five-page EMS report for O'Keefe, recording response and treatment times, interventions and observations. Its narrative does not mention a vehicle strike.
Trial 14 mentionsKaren Read Voicemails to O'Keefe (Jan 29, 2022) — Eight voicemails from Read to O'Keefe between about 12:37 and 6:08 a.m. on January 29, including a final message capturing someone on a 911 call.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsKelly Dever August 9, 2023 Law Enforcement Interview Report — Report of Kelly Dever's August 9, 2023 law-enforcement interview, recording her account of Higgins and Berkowitz in the sallyport with Read's SUV and her friendship with Sarah Levinson.
Trial 24 mentionsPollock et al. — 'Fatal Dog Bite Injuries' (Univ. of Vienna) — Pollock and colleagues' peer-reviewed study of fatal dog bites, describing how injury forms vary with body surface, underlying structures and intervening textiles.
Trial 24 mentionsProctor Report of McCabe Interview (January 29, 2022) — Trooper Michael Proctor's report and interview notes from his January 29, 2022 interview with Jennifer McCabe, documenting her account of the morning's events and her description of Read's SUV taillight.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsRead–O'Keefe Text Messages (Jan 28–29, 2022) — Read–O'Keefe texts from the evening of January 28 into January 29, covering an argument, evening plans and Read's messages about going home, extracted from both phones.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsSergeant Lank's Police Report (January 29, 2022) — Sergeant Michael Lank's Canton Police incident report from January 29, 2022, documenting interviews at Brian Albert's house and statements made that morning.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsBecker / Canton Fire Engine 3 Ambulance Run Report — Becker's Canton Fire ambulance report for the January 29 Section 12 call, documenting Read's vital signs, statements and history, including the word 'argument' in the notes.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsCanton DPW Plow Plan — January 28–29, 2022 Storm (Exhibit 109) — Canton Department of Public Works plow plan for the January 28–29, 2022 blizzard, documenting truck assignments, driver names, route numbers, and deployment schedule.
Trial 13 mentionsCanton PD Key Card Access Logs (January 29, 2022) — Canton Police Department key card entry and exit logs documenting personnel movements into and out of the station on January 29, 2022, spanning 167 pages and approximately 4,500 total entries.
Trial 13 mentionsHiggins–O'Keefe Text Messages — Higgins–O'Keefe texts about their social interactions, including an unanswered January 29 invitation from 34 Fairview and a February 3 exchange.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsJennifer McCabe 911 Call (6:04 AM, Jan 29, 2022) — McCabe's 6:04 a.m. 911 recording from 34 Fairview, reporting a man outside and describing O'Keefe's condition, including her statement 'he got out of the car.'
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsJennifer McCabe Cell Phone Consent Form (Feb. 2, 2022) — Cell phone consent form signed by Jennifer McCabe on February 2, 2022, at 12:08 PM, surrendering her iPhone 11 (with IMEI number and password) to law enforcement. Admitted as Exhibit 81 in Trial 2.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsJennifer McCabe Grand Jury Transcript (Apr. 26, 2022) — Grand jury transcript of Jennifer McCabe's sworn testimony from April 26, 2022, running approximately 222–227 pages.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsKerry Roberts Grand Jury Transcript (Apr. 26, 2022) — Grand jury transcript of Kerry Roberts's testimony from April 26, 2022, including page 83, line 19.
Trial 23 mentionsMcCabe Deleted Call Records (Cellebrite / Biome Recovery) — McCabe call logs marked deleted from 5:33:47 to 8:50:05 a.m.; Green opined they were manually deleted. Recovered Biome entries included calls to Nicole Albert at 6:08 and 6:42.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsMcCabe–O'Keefe Calls — Arrival Window (Jan 29 AM) — Call records showing McCabe's direction calls to O'Keefe and seven missed calls between 12:29 and 12:50 a.m. that do not appear in her own phone extraction.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsNOAA Norwood Airport Weather Data (January 2022) — NOAA climatological data and certified January 2022 weather records from Norwood Memorial Airport, about one mile from 34 Fairview, including hourly observations and wind speeds.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsO'Keefe Right Hand / Wrist X-ray (229A) — Radiograph of John O'Keefe's right hand and wrist taken at the medical examiner's office, showing no fractures, deformities, or abnormalities.
Trial 23 mentions2008 NAS Report on Forensic Odontology — 2008 National Academy of Sciences report on forensic odontology, addressing the reliability of bite mark identification and the recognition of animal attack injury patterns.
Trial 12 mentionsARCCA / Wolfe Defense Communication Records — Wolfe's Verizon records and ARCCA communication chart, mostly showing brief logistical contacts with the defense. He could not produce T-Mobile records from before his November carrier switch.
Trial 22 mentionsBrian Albert Phone Preservation Order (Sep. 2022) — Court-issued preservation order and associated Commonwealth letter, dated September 22–23, 2022, requiring Brian Albert to preserve his cell phone.
Trial 12 mentionsBrian Albert Phone Records (Number ending 0888) — Brian Albert phone records showing the 2:22 a.m. Higgins exchange and later calls to Higgins, McCabe and family. Albert said the records shown were selective, not complete.
Trial 12 mentionsBrian Higgins June 1, 2023 Hearing Transcript — Transcript of Brian Higgins's sworn testimony at a June 1, 2023 hearing.
Trial 12 mentionsBurgess CV in Texas Federal Court Filing (Exhibits EE, FF, 193) — Burgess's CV and docket filing, admitted together as Exhibit 193. The CV misstated his degree status; Burgess said the BGS was being pursued and 2024 was his expected completion year.
Trial 22 mentionsCamerano–O'Keefe Texts (Jan 28–29, 2022) — January 28–29 texts involving Michael and Katie Camerano and O'Keefe, including two unanswered messages Katie sent at 5:10 a.m. on January 29.
Trial 12 mentionsCanton PD Dispatch Log (January 29, 2022) — The Canton Police Department dispatch log documenting emergency calls and unit responses on January 29, 2022. Contains the recorded arrival order, arrival times, and the address logged for the O'Keefe call.
Trial 12 mentionsCARS Report (Crime Scene Mapping Document) — A CARS (crime scene documentation) report recording the search performed at 34 Fairview Road, including drone imagery captured by the CARS team using a DJI Mavic 2 drone.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsColin Albert MSP Interview Report (July 18, 2023) — The Massachusetts State Police interview report for Colin Albert, dated July 18, 2023, authored by Trooper Michael Proctor.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsCourt Production Order for ARCCA/Wolfe Records — Court order requiring ARCCA and Dr. Wolfe to produce responsive communications and records within their possession, custody, or control relating to Commonwealth v. Read.
Trial 22 mentionsDaniel Whitley Grand Jury Transcript (Apr. 21, 2022) — Grand jury transcript of Canton firefighter Daniel Whitley's testimony from April 21, 2022.
Trial 22 mentionsGood Samaritan ETOH (Alcohol) Testing Policy — Good Samaritan Medical Center's formal policy document governing procedures for alcohol blood testing, including the requirement for a non-alcohol swab.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsGood Samaritan Patient Specimen Collection Policy — Good Samaritan Medical Center's formal policy governing patient preparation, phlebotomy procedures, patient identification, and quality controls for blood specimen collection.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsGoode Report Face Sheets — Two Printed Versions — Two printed versions of the face sheet of Sergeant Sean Goode's police report: the original printed January 30, 2022 bearing a berm photo, and a later version printed October 25, 2022 bearing a taillight piece photo.
Trial 12 mentionsHiggins Phone Preservation Order (Sep. 30, 2022) — Court preservation order served on Brian Higgins on or around September 30, 2022, requiring preservation of his phone.
Trial 12 mentionsJason Becker Grand Jury Transcript (Apr. 21, 2022) — Grand jury transcript of Jason Becker's testimony from April 21, 2022, including page 81, lines 1–4.
Trial 22 mentionsJennifer McCabe June 2023 Hearing Transcript — Transcript of Jennifer McCabe's sworn testimony at a June 2023 hearing, with pages referenced including pages 782–783 and 816–817.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsJennifer McCabe Trial 1 Testimony Transcript (May 17, 2024) — Transcript of Jennifer McCabe's Trial 1 testimony from May 17, 2024, including pages RT 114–115.
Trial 22 mentionsJulie Albert–Courtney Proctor Call Records (Feb–Sep 2022) — Records of 67 calls between Julie Albert and Courtney Proctor from February to September 2022, including calls around Read's arrest and arraignment and a February 10 exchange.
Trial 12 mentionsKaren Read Call Log (Jan 29, 2022) — Read's Phone — Full call log extracted from Karen Read's phone covering January 29, 2022 from approximately 12:33 AM to 6:03 AM, documenting all calls to and from Read's device during that period.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsKaren Read Recorded Police Interview Clips — Video clips from Karen Read's police interviews, played for the jury during Trial 2 closings and deliberations.
Trial 22 mentionsKaren Read's Phone — Missed Calls (Shown to Becker) — Karen Read's phone, which she showed to Canton firefighter Jason Becker at the scene, displaying missed calls from the overnight hours.
Trial 22 mentionsMcCabe–O'Keefe Texts — Arrival/Direction Messages (Jan 29 AM) — McCabe–O'Keefe texts from the arrival window: his 12:14 a.m. request for directions and her messages from 12:27 through 12:45, including 'pull behind me.'
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsMcCabe–Proctor Call Records (Jan–Mar 2022) — Verizon phone records documenting phone calls between Jennifer McCabe and Trooper Michael Proctor from January 29 through March 2022, introduced as two separate exhibits covering different date ranges.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsMSP Trooper Group Chat — August 17, 2022 — MSP group texts containing derogatory remarks about Read. Bukhenik said his thumbs-up acknowledged Proctor searching her phone rather than a specific derogatory message.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsO'Keefe Death Certificate (Amended) — O'Keefe's death certificate lists blunt head impact injuries and hypothermia as the cause and an undetermined manner of death. An amended version was introduced in Trial 2.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsO'Keefe Phone Call Register — O'Keefe's January 28–29 call register, including McCabe's pre-arrival calls, Read's 12:33 a.m. call and seven further Read calls as battery temperature fell.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsO'Keefe Right Forearm X-ray (229B) — Radiograph of John O'Keefe's right forearm from the medical examiner's office, showing no fractures or signs of trauma to the forearm bones.
Trial 22 mentionsO'Keefe Right Upper Arm / Humerus X-ray (229C) — Radiograph of John O'Keefe's right humerus and shoulder area from the medical examiner's office, showing no injuries to the upper arm bone or the shoulder and elbow joints.
Trial 22 mentionsRead–Camerano Texts (Jan 29, 2022) — Read–Katie Camerano texts from the January 29 search, including Read's statements 'He's dead' and 'Last he was in the snow' at 6:34–6:36 a.m.
Trial 12 mentionsRead–Kerry Roberts Call Log — Call log extraction report documenting phone communications between Karen Read and Kerry Roberts on January 29, 2022.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsRead–McCabe Communications (Calls and Texts) — Records of phone calls and text messages between Karen Read and Jennifer McCabe around the time of O'Keefe's death, covering both the immediate night and subsequent days.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsRing Corporation Search Warrant Return and Activity Logs — Ring Corporation search warrant return including login session reports and account activity logs, produced in response to a law enforcement search warrant.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsRMV Records for Karen Read's Lexus LX — Massachusetts RMV title history and registration records for Karen Read's 2022 black Lexus LX, registration 3GC684, establishing vehicle ownership and registration history.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsRyan Nagel Text Message Screenshot (Ride Time) — A screenshot of a text message from Ryan Nagel, collected from his sister Julie Nagel by Jennifer McCabe rather than by investigators, used to establish the time Nagel arrived at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsState Police Crime Lab Toxicology Report (O'Keefe) — The State Police crime laboratory toxicology report for John O'Keefe reflecting a blood alcohol concentration of 0.21 and vitreous humor alcohol of 0.28, with no illicit drugs detected.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsTrial 2 Sealed Verdict Slip — Trial 2 verdict slip sealed in an envelope and marked for identification with the jury before jurors retracted their indication that they had reached a verdict.
Trial 22 mentionsTrooper Nicholas Gino's Report — A report authored by Trooper Nicholas Gino, reviewed during both trials in connection with the evidence and scene measurements at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsTully Interview Report of Gallagher (April 2024) — Lieutenant Brian Tully's report documenting his April 2024 interview with Canton PD Lieutenant Paul Gallagher, conducted approximately two years after the incident.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentions2005 Rhode Island DOH Audit of Medical Examiner's Office — 2005 Rhode Island Department of Health audit of the Medical Examiner's office.
Trial 21 mentionARCCA Invoice to Werksman Jackson Firm (Jul. 2024) — Invoice from ARCCA to the Werksman Jackson law firm dated July 2024.
Trial 21 mentionAutopsy Attendance Log — The log recording individuals present at John O'Keefe's autopsy.
Trial 21 mentionAVL/GeoTab GPS Vehicle Locator Records — Automatic vehicle locator records from the GeoTab GPS system providing precise arrival times for SERT team members at the scene.
Trial 11 mentionBar Surveillance Video Analysis Reports (McCarthy's and Waterfall) — Reports analyzing the surveillance footage from both C.F. McCarthy's and Waterfall Bar & Grille, authored by Trooper Michael Proctor following retrieval of the videos by Connor Keefe.
Trial 21 mentionBarros Police Report (January 29, 2022) — Dighton PD Officer Nicholas Barros's police report from January 29, 2022, containing a single line describing damage to Read's vehicle: 'The vehicle had damage to the right rear tail light.'
Trial 21 mentionBecker Incident Report ("Earlier in the Night") — Jason Becker's own incident report documenting that an argument between Read and O'Keefe occurred 'earlier in the night.'
Trial 21 mentionBlogger Article About Brian Loughran (June 5, 2023) — Blogger article dated June 5, 2023 about Brian Loughran.
Trial 21 mentionBrian Albert Jr. Grand Jury Testimony (May 18, 2023) — Grand jury testimony of Brian Albert Jr. from May 18, 2023, concerning his recollections of Brian Higgins's presence and his father Brian Albert's movements on the relevant evening.
Trial 11 mentionBrian Higgins May 2023 Interview Statement — A statement given by Brian Higgins to investigators in approximately May 2023.
Trial 11 mentionBrian Loughran May 2023 Interview Report — A law enforcement interview report from May 2023 documenting statements made by Brian Loughran regarding his observations and timeline.
Trial 11 mentionBrian Loughran Trial 1 Testimony Transcript (Jun. 21, 2024) — Transcript of Brian Loughran's Trial 1 testimony from June 21, 2024.
Trial 21 mentionBukhenik Interview Notes of Flematti (February 8, 2022) — Sergeant Yuri Bukhenik's notes from a February 8, 2022 interview with witness Anthony Flematti documenting statements attributed to Karen Read.
Trial 11 mentionBukhenik Photographs of O'Keefe at Good Samaritan Hospital — Bukhenik's hospital photographs of O'Keefe, documenting facial injuries, eye swelling, a nostril laceration and linear abrasions concentrated on the right arm.
Trial 11 mentionBukhenik Police Report — Scene (Second Page) — The second page of Sergeant Yuri Bukhenik's police report from the January 29, 2022 scene at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionBukhenik Report of D'Antuono Interview (September 2, 2023) — Sergeant Yuri Bukhenik's report documenting a September 2, 2023 interview with night-of witness Ricky D'Antuono.
Trial 21 mentionBukhenik Report to the Medical Examiner's Office — Sergeant Yuri Bukhenik's report to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner describing the injuries observed on John O'Keefe.
Trial 11 mentionCanton PD Dispatch Room Security Monitors — Security monitors in the Canton PD dispatch room showing internal camera feeds, including views of sallyport activity.
Trial 21 mentionCanton PD Roll Call / Press Log (Exhibit 14) — A running journal of Canton Police Department activity for the shift on January 29, 2022, created by Officer Kelly Dever.
Trial 11 mentionCAP Proficiency Testing: Enzymatic vs. GC — CAP proficiency testing results comparing enzymatic and headspace gas chromatography laboratories.
Trial 21 mentionCERT Search Report (Not Admitted) — A report detailing the search performed by the Critical Emergency Response Team at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionChain of Custody — Hoodie and Lab Cuttings (Exhibit BBB) — A chain of custody document for the hoodie and laboratory cuttings taken from it, admitted for identification as Exhibit BBB in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionChris Albert–O'Keefe Texts ('Nebbercracker') — Text messages from Chris Albert to John O'Keefe stating 'Get over here' and 'If not, I'm going to f up your lawn,' introduced as part of a larger exhibit.
Trial 11 mentionCommonwealth Memorandum Opposing Text Message Admission — Commonwealth's memorandum in opposition to the admission of certain text messages, citing cases including Pertie, Welch, Carmel v. Reposa, and Sullivan.
Trial 21 mentionCommonwealth Motion re Defense Expert Testimony (Exhibit 45) — Commonwealth's motion regarding defense expert testimony, marked as Exhibit 45 in Trial 2, filed June 5—past the March 7 deadline.
Trial 21 mentionCommonwealth v. Coleman, 366 Mass. 705 — Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court decision in Commonwealth v. Coleman, 366 Mass. 705.
Trial 21 mentionCommonwealth v. Hills, 105 Mass. App. Ct. 1124 (2025) — Massachusetts Appeals Court decision in Commonwealth v. Hills, 105 Mass. App. Ct. 1124 (2025).
Trial 21 mentionCrime Lab Chain of Custody — Glass (Case 22-02184, Exhibit BV) — Chain of custody document for crime lab case number 22-02184, related to the glass evidence analyzed by Christina Hanley.
Trial 11 mentionCriminal Acquittal of Mark and Alfredo Lalo — Record of the criminal case acquittal of Mark and Alfredo Lalo, the men involved in the 2002 incident with Sgt. Michael Lank.
Trial 11 mentionDaniel Whitley February 8, 2022 Interview Report — A report documenting the February 8, 2022 police interview of Canton Fire Lieutenant Daniel Whitley, conducted by Michael Proctor among others, approximately ten days after the incident.
Trial 21 mentionDaniel Whitley Trial 1 Testimony Transcript (2024) — Transcript of Daniel Whitley's Trial 1 testimony from 2024.
Trial 21 mentionDefense PI Report of Loughran Interview — A report prepared by a defense private investigator documenting the initial interview with Brian Loughran.
Trial 21 mentionDefense Proposed Alternative Verdict Form (Exhibit LL) — Defense-proposed sequential verdict form providing a not-guilty option at each lesser-included-offense level, marked for identification as Exhibit LL in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionDever Sallyport Timeline — SUV Arrival After Shift End — A timeline document shown to Kelly Dever at trial establishing that Karen Read's SUV arrived at the sallyport approximately 90 minutes after Dever's shift ended at 3:45 PM.
Trial 21 mentionDiagram of Canine Dental Anatomy — Demonstrative diagram of canine dental anatomy used to explain dog dentition, triangular jaw shape, and how canine teeth create puncture wounds.
Trial 21 mentionDiCicco's Handwritten Notes on Ring Video — 12:41 AM Clip — DiCicco's notes refer to a now-missing 12:41 a.m. Ring clip of taillights, with 'I think she arrived home.' The clip was omitted from Proctor's report.
Trial 11 mentionDr. Marie Russell December 2024 Hearing Transcript (Exhibit 24) — Transcript of Dr. Marie Russell's testimony at a December 2024 hearing, including page 100, admitted as Exhibit 24 in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionDr. Marie Russell June 18, 2024 Hearing Transcript — Transcript of Dr. Marie Russell's testimony at a June 18, 2024 hearing.
Trial 21 mentionDr. Marie Russell June 21, 2024 Hearing Transcript — Transcript of Dr. Marie Russell's testimony at a June 21, 2024 hearing.
Trial 21 mentionDr. Russell December 12, 2024 Lanigan Hearing Transcript — Transcript of Dr. Marie Russell's testimony at the December 12, 2024 Lanigan (Daubert) hearing.
Trial 21 mentionDr. Russell's Professional Listing Website — Russell's professional listing website featuring a trial photograph.
Trial 21 mentionEvidence Bag Photograph — Item 7-12 (Exhibit HHH) — Item 7-12 bag photograph with a label appearing to name Bukhenik. Hanley identified the name as a LIMS description and was unsure who recovered the pieces.
Trial 21 mentionEvidence Bag Photograph — Item 7-14 (Exhibit III) — A photograph of the evidence bag associated with item 7-14, admitted as Exhibit III; Hanley said the hard-to-read label could say Trooper Proctor.
Trial 21 mentionEvidence Bags with Exterior Notations (January 29 Search) — Evidence bags with handwritten exterior notations from the January 29, 2022 evidence collection at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionExhibit 155 (Redacted Pre-Deliberation) — An exhibit requiring a single-line redaction agreed to by both sides, processed during final exhibit preparation before jury deliberations.
Trial 21 mentionFederal Law Enforcement Interview Report of McCabe (April 2023) — A report from a separate law enforcement agency's April 2023 interview with Jennifer McCabe.
Trial 21 mentionFederal Law Enforcement Interview Report of Roberts — A report from a federal law enforcement interview of Kerry Roberts, referenced at page 7.
Trial 21 mentionFirst Responder Accounts of Read's Statements — Lally's directed-verdict argument aggregated first-responder testimony about statements attributed to Read, including "I hit him"; no separate report or exhibit is identified.
Trial 11 mentionGoode Police Report (Incident 2287, Multiple Errors) — Sergeant Sean Goode's police report for incident 2287 (call 22-44) documenting the response to the O'Keefe call on January 29, 2022.
Trial 11 mentionGoogle Maps Route Distance Calculations — Google Maps calculations of route distances for the defendant's known travel route.
Trial 11 mentionGPS Evidence Recovery Diagrams (Exhibits 135–136) — GPS-generated diagrams mapping the locations where evidence was recovered relative to the flagpole, fire hydrant, and house at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionGuarino Report — O'Keefe Phone Chain of Custody — Trooper Nicholas Guarino's February 4, 2022 police report describing the chain of custody for John O'Keefe's phone.
Trial 11 mentionHoodie Evidence Bag Label (Exhibit 154) — Label for the hoodie and T-shirt evidence bag. Hartnett could read the displayed label but knew custody only from its delivery to the lab by the Norfolk Detective Unit.
Trial 21 mentionJackson–Wolfe Engagement Letter Email (Mar. 20, 2024) — Email from defense attorney Alan Jackson to Dr. Wolfe dated March 20, 2024, regarding an engagement letter.
Trial 21 mentionJason Becker Trial 1 Testimony Transcript (May 3, 2024) — Transcript of Jason Becker's Trial 1 testimony from May 3, 2024, page 10, lines 9–13.
Trial 21 mentionJessica Hyde Trial 1 Testimony Transcript (Jun. 2024) — Transcript of digital forensics expert Jessica Hyde's Trial 1 testimony from June 2024.
Trial 21 mentionKaren Read Audio Statement (June 9, 2022) — An audio recording of a statement made by Karen Read on June 9, 2022, in which she referenced her taillight.
Trial 11 mentionKaren Read Chat Report (Jan 29 Onward) — Read's chat extraction from January 29 onward, including her messages to Laura Sullivan and O'Keefe and her statement that she found him in snow at 5 a.m. and did not enter the party.
Trial 11 mentionKaren Read's C.F. McCarthy's Tab ($52.80, Tito's Vodka) — Transaction receipts from C.F. McCarthy's showing Karen Read's bar tab of $52.80, listing Tito's vodka, paid using John O'Keefe's MasterCard.
Trial 11 mentionKatie McLaughlin Trial 1 Testimony Transcript (May 3, 2024) — Transcript of paramedic Katie McLaughlin's Trial 1 testimony from May 3, 2024, pages 10-24 and 10-56.
Trial 21 mentionKeeper of Records Certificates (Series) — A series of keeper of records certificates marked for identification to authenticate business records.
Trial 21 mentionKerry Roberts 911 Call (approx. 5 AM, Jan 29, 2022) — Audio recording of Kerry Roberts's 911 call to Canton police at approximately 5 AM on January 29, 2022, reporting O'Keefe's disappearance.
Trial 11 mentionKerry Roberts Canton PD Non-Emergency Call — Audio recording of Kerry Roberts's call to the Canton police non-emergency line, corroborating Roberts's account of the search timeline and her level of concern.
Trial 21 mentionKevin O'Hara Grand Jury Transcript (May 5, 2022) — Grand jury transcript of Canton Police Lt. Kevin O'Hara's testimony from May 5, 2022.
Trial 21 mentionKevin O'Hara Trial 1 Testimony Transcript (Jun. 2024) — Transcript of Canton Police Lt. Kevin O'Hara's Trial 1 testimony from June 2024.
Trial 21 mentionKinetic Energy Formula Demonstrative — Demonstrative exhibit presenting the kinetic energy formula (E_k = ½mv²).
Trial 21 mentionLalo Brothers Complaint — Police Reports (September 2002) — Police reports from September 2002 documenting a complaint by the Lalo brothers involving Chris Albert and Sergeant Michael Lank.
Trial 11 mentionLalo Brothers Federal Civil Lawsuit Against Sgt. Lank — Federal civil lawsuit filed by the Lalo brothers against Canton Police Sgt. Michael Lank arising from a 2002 physical altercation, which resulted in a settlement with a non-disclosure agreement.
Trial 11 mentionLeaf Blower Used at Scene (Lt. Gallagher) — Leaf blower used by Lt. Gallagher to mechanically clear snow from the area where O'Keefe's body was found.
Trial 11 mentionLucas Machine Illustrations and CT Scan (Medical Literature) — Medical literature illustrations of the Lucas mechanical chest compression device and associated CT scan imagery.
Trial 21 mentionMagnet AXIOM Artifact Reference Guide — Magnet AXIOM artifact reference guide, a published resource from the digital forensics software.
Trial 21 mentionMatthew McCabe Grand Jury Transcript (Apr. 26, 2022) — Grand jury transcript of Matthew McCabe's sworn testimony from April 26, 2022, admitted as Exhibit 2103 in Trial 1.
Trial 11 mentionMatthew McCabe Texts to O'Keefe (Jan 29) — Text messages from Matthew McCabe to John O'Keefe on January 29, 2022 asking where he was, which received no response.
Trial 11 mentionMcCabe 105+ Deleted Texts (30-Day Auto-Delete) — More than 105 text messages subject to a 30-day auto-delete policy on McCabe's phone, noted by the judge as a significant evidence preservation concern in a pending case.
Trial 21 mentionMcCabe Complete Text Record (Jan 29–31, 2022) — McCabe's January 29–31 text records, including exchanges with Kerry Roberts and Nicole Albert expressing shock and grief, subject to agreed redactions before admission.
Trial 21 mentionMcCabe Phone Records — 5:07 AM Call to Albert Residence — Jennifer McCabe's phone records showing a call to Brian Albert's house at 5:07 AM on January 29, 2022.
Trial 21 mentionMcCabe-to-Read Text Chain (7:26 AM — 'Cari's Number') — Text message chain in which Jennifer McCabe asked Karen Read for 'Cari's number' at 7:26 AM on January 29, 2022.
Trial 21 mentionMcCabe–Nicole Albert 'Kerry Talked to Cops' Texts — McCabe–Nicole Albert texts around 7:54–8:01 p.m. on January 29, including 'Kerry talked to the cops and kept it simple' and Albert's response, 'don't want to text about it.'
Trial 21 mentionMcCabe–Roberts Texts (Post-Interview Coordination) — Text message records between Jennifer McCabe and Kerry Roberts around the time of Roberts's January 29, 2022 police interview.
Trial 21 mentionMcLaughlin–Albert social media friends list printout — Social media printout showing Caitlin Albert's friends list with Katie McLaughlin listed as a connection.
Trial 11 mentionMertz/Backaitis Literature on Hybrid III Dummy Limitations — Published literature by Harold Mertz and Stanley Backaitis on the limitations of the Hybrid III crash test dummy.
Trial 21 mentionMichael Camerano Grand Jury Testimony — Grand jury testimony of Michael Camerano concerning his observations of Karen Read and John O'Keefe's interactions on the night in question.
Trial 11 mentionMission Manager Software Reports — Reports generated by Mission Manager software providing more detailed operational documentation of the SERT search beyond what appeared in the Daily Journal.
Trial 11 mentionMS Patient Lactic Acid Study (Italy and Netherlands) — Study of 600 MS patients from centers in Italy and the Netherlands examining lactic acid levels.
Trial 21 mentionMullaney Police Report — Officer Steven Mullaney's police report documenting his response to the O'Keefe scene on January 29, 2022.
Trial 11 mentionNicholas Barros Trial 1 Testimony Transcript (Jun. 10, 2024) — Transcript of Dighton Police Officer Nicholas Barros's Trial 1 testimony from June 10, 2024.
Trial 21 mentionNicole Albert Cellebrite — McCabe 6:07/6:08 AM Calls — Cellebrite extraction of Nicole Albert's phone showing two incoming calls from Jennifer McCabe at 6:07 and 6:08 AM on January 29, 2022.
Trial 11 mentionNOAA Snow Depth Maps — Greater Boston (Exhibits 62–63) — NOAA snow depth maps of the greater Boston area at 1:00 a.m. and 7:00 a.m. on January 29, 2022, showing snow accumulation progression.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Arm X-ray Stipulated Set — Right-hand/wrist, forearm, and upper-arm X-ray images of John O'Keefe that both parties agreed could be admitted through Dr. Rentschler.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Prescribed Medications / Medical History Records — Medical records for John O'Keefe listing his prescribed medications, including omeprazole, a proton pump inhibitor.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Preserved Brain Tissue (Physical Specimen) — The preserved brain tissue of John O'Keefe, which served as the primary physical subject of Dr. Renee Stonebridge's neuropathological examination.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Right Sneaker (Good Samaritan Hospital) — John O'Keefe's right sneaker recovered from Good Samaritan Hospital.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe–Chris Albert Chat Extraction — Extracted chat report from John O'Keefe's phone documenting communications between O'Keefe and Chris Albert.
Trial 11 mentionOpen Voicemail — Ambient Scene Audio (Read Screaming) — A voicemail recording captured inside McCabe's SUV that recorded ambient audio from the scene, including the 911 call and Karen Read screaming hysterically while Kerry Roberts attempted to calm her.
Trial 11 mentionPatino Case Transcript (page 1025) — Transcript from the Patino case, page 1025, cited during argument over Dr. Laposata's expert testimony.
Trial 21 mentionPolice Report in Scordi-Bello File — 11 Lines (Exhibit QQ) — An 11-line police report found in Medical Examiner Dr. Irini Scordi-Bello's file, initiated January 29 at 1941, marked as Exhibit QQ for identification.
Trial 21 mentionPolice Report in Scordi-Bello File — 5 Lines (Exhibit RR) — A second, five-line police report found in Medical Examiner Dr. Irini Scordi-Bello's file, marked as Exhibit RR for identification.
Trial 21 mentionPost-Trial 1 Photograph of Brian Loughran — Photograph of Brian Loughran taken after his Trial 1 testimony, admitted with redactions.
Trial 21 mentionPrecision Weather Forecast Report (Exhibit 61) — A storm warning report issued by Precision Weather Forecasting at 8:00 p.m. on January 28, 2022, with detailed 6-hour snowfall projections, temperature forecasts, and wind conditions.
Trial 21 mentionPreviously Marked Exhibit 577 (T1) — A previously marked exhibit referenced during exhibit identification at the start of recross examination.
Trial 11 mentionPrior Los Angeles Pedestrian Fatality Case Materials — Case materials from a prior Los Angeles pedestrian fatality case.
Trial 21 mentionProctor at Good Samaritan Hospital — Clothing Photograph — A photograph depicting Trooper Michael Proctor at Good Samaritan Hospital with John O'Keefe's clothing on the floor.
Trial 11 mentionProctor Handwritten Notes — Nagel Interview — Handwritten notes from Trooper Michael Proctor's interview with night-of witness Julie Nagel, listing persons present at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionProctor Prior Proceeding Testimony (Exhibits 01562–01564) — Three pages of Trooper Michael Proctor's prior proceeding testimony regarding his disclosures about relationships with the Albert family, marked as Exhibits 01562–01564 in Trial 1.
Trial 11 mentionProctor Report (November 4, 2023) — February Searches — A police report authored by Trooper Michael Proctor on November 4, 2023, documenting the February 4 and February 10, 2022 searches at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionProctor Report of Becker Interview (February 14, 2022) — Trooper Michael Proctor's two-page report documenting a February 14, 2022 interview with Canton Fire Lieutenant Jason Becker.
Trial 11 mentionProctor Report of McLaughlin Interview (January 30, 2022) — Trooper Michael Proctor's report documenting his January 30, 2022 interview with paramedic Katie McLaughlin.
Trial 11 mentionProctor Report of Nagel Interview (October 2022) — Trooper Michael Proctor's interview report of night-of witness Julie Nagel, conducted in October 2022.
Trial 11 mentionProctor Report of Nuttall Interview (February 8, 2022) — Trooper Michael Proctor's report documenting a February 8, 2022 interview with Canton Fire EMS Lieutenant Tim Nuttall.
Trial 21 mentionProctor Report of Saraf Interview (January 30, 2022) — Trooper Michael Proctor's report documenting his January 30, 2022 interview with Officer Steven Saraf, conducted the day after the incident.
Trial 11 mentionProctor–DiCicco Texts re Autopsy and ME Pressure — Proctor–DiCicco texts about the undetermined manner of death, including DiCicco's criticism, and Proctor's testimony about calls and photographs sent to the medical examiner.
Trial 11 mentionProctor–Galanis Texts re Surveillance Cameras — Proctor–Galanis texts seeking surveillance help despite Canton PD's recusal. Proctor said he did not retrieve the possible school or gas-station footage and did not believe the inquiry was reported.
Trial 11 mentionProctor–Kevin Albert Texts (Cold Case / Badge) — Text communications between Trooper Michael Proctor and Kevin Albert regarding cold case work and badge retrieval.
Trial 11 mentionProctor–Sister Courtney Texts — Proctor's texts with his sister Courtney, including case details, a wish that Read would kill herself and a reference to Julie Albert offering a thank-you gift before her interview.
Trial 11 mentionRainey Study on Serum-to-Blood Conversion Rates — Peer-reviewed study by Rainey on serum-to-blood alcohol conversion rates.
Trial 21 mentionRead–Camerano Phone Calls (Jan 29, 2022) — Phone call records between Karen Read and Katie Camerano documenting six calls between 4:49 AM and 6:44 AM on January 29, 2022, establishing the timeline and duration of their communications that morning.
Trial 11 mentionRead–Curtis/Ingrid Group Chat (Jan 29, 2022) — Text messages between Karen Read and a group chat including Ingrid and Bill Curtis on January 29, 2022, covering communications in the morning after O'Keefe's death.
Trial 21 mentionRead–O'Keefe Call Log (T2 Exhibit 25) — Call log records between John O'Keefe and Karen Read from January 28–29, 2022, introduced as a distinct exhibit in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionRead–O'Keefe Communication Compilation (PowerPoint + USB) — A jury-presentation binder with a chronological PowerPoint of Read–O'Keefe calls, texts and voicemails, accompanied by a USB drive containing the voicemail audio.
Trial 21 mentionRead–O'Keefe Facebook Messenger Chat (O'Keefe's Phone) — A Facebook Messenger chat report extracted from John O'Keefe's phone documenting communications between Karen Read and O'Keefe.
Trial 11 mentionRedacted Handwriting Comparison Document — Redacted document used to compare handwriting on evidence bag 111 with known Trooper Proctor notes.
Trial 21 mentionRedirect Photograph (Exhibit 201A) — Photograph published at the start of redirect examination during Russell's testimony.
Trial 21 mentionRentschler Defense Communication Records — Phone call records between defense expert Dr. Andrew Rentschler and the defense team, showing a discrepancy between defense records (23 calls) and Rentschler's own records (3 calls).
Trial 21 mentionRing Video Certification Document (Exhibit 12B) — Ring Corporation certification document admitted as Exhibit 12B in Trial 2, introduced through Kerry Roberts.
Trial 21 mentionRoberts–Nelson Texts re Ring Camera Replacement — Text messages between Kerry Roberts and victim advocate Steve Nelson dated March 7, 2023, concerning the replacement of the O'Keefes' driveway Ring camera.
Trial 21 mentionRyan Nagel May 2023 Interview Report — A non-Commonwealth report from a May 2023 interview with night-of witness Ryan Nagel.
Trial 11 mentionRyan Nagel Prior Hearing Transcript (May 2022) — Transcript of Ryan Nagel's testimony from a May 2022 hearing concerning the duration of a conversation with Julie Nagel.
Trial 11 mentionSaraf Incident Report (January 29, 2022) — Officer Steven Saraf's incident report dated January 29, 2022, documenting his response to the O'Keefe scene.
Trial 11 mentionSarah Levinson Hearing Transcript (May 11, 2023) — Transcript of Sarah Levinson's testimony at a hearing held May 11, 2023.
Trial 11 mentionSarah Levinson Interview Report (October 21, 2022) — An interview report dated October 21, 2022 for night-of witness Sarah Levinson, authored by Trooper Michael Proctor with Trooper Keefe assisting.
Trial 21 mentionScordi-Bello Grand Jury Testimony — The grand jury testimony of Dr. Irini Scordi-Bello regarding John O'Keefe's autopsy and cause-of-death findings.
Trial 21 mentionSearch Warrant and Police Report Binder (Tabs 1–13) — A binder of search warrants and police reports organized into thirteen tabbed sections, including warrants ending in 07, 13, 14, 04, and 77, and an evidence submission form from March 14, 2022.
Trial 21 mentionSERT Daily Journal — The daily operational journal maintained by the State Emergency Response Team during the January 29, 2022 search at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionSERT Final Mission Report — The final mission report prepared by the State Emergency Response Team following the January 29, 2022 search at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionSERT Personnel Status Report — The personnel status report for the State Emergency Response Team documenting arrival times for team members during the January 29, 2022 search.
Trial 11 mentionShanon Burgess LinkedIn Profile Printout — Printout of Aperture analyst Shanon Burgess's LinkedIn profile.
Trial 21 mentionState v. Herrera — Maryland Court Decision (Exhibit CC) — Certified Maryland decision in State v. Herrera on excluding Hyde's significant-location testimony under Daubert, marked for identification as Exhibit CC in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionSteven Saraf Grand Jury Testimony (Apr. 14, 2022) — Grand jury testimony of Canton Police Officer Steven Saraf given April 14, 2022, concerning the events surrounding the discovery of John O'Keefe's body.
Trial 11 mentionStipulated Defense Documents — Hartnett (Exhibits 152–154) — Three defense documents entered into evidence by stipulation at the start of cross-examination of Maureen Hartnett, admitted as Exhibits 152, 153, and 154 in Trial 2. Specific contents were not discussed on the record.
Trial 21 mentionStipulated Hourly Snowfall Chart (Exhibit 64) — A stipulated chart showing estimated hourly snowfall accumulation for January 29, 2022.
Trial 21 mentionStipulation: Higgins Text to O'Keefe at 12:20 AM (Jan. 29, 2022) — Stipulated fact that Brian Higgins texted John O'Keefe 'You coming here???' at 12:20 AM on January 29, 2022.
Trial 21 mentionStonebridge Neuropathology Report (O'Keefe Brain) — Stonebridge's neuropathology report on O'Keefe's preserved brain tissue, addressing subarachnoid and brain-stem hemorrhage, contusions and herniation.
Trial 11 mentionSupporting Records Reviewed by Dr. Stonebridge — A collection of supporting materials reviewed by Dr. Renee Stonebridge alongside her brain examination, including autopsy photos, police reports, EMS reports, hospital medical records, and primary care records.
Trial 11 mentionTim Nuttall Trial 1 Testimony Transcript (Apr. 30, 2024) — Transcript of Canton Fire paramedic Tim Nuttall's Trial 1 testimony from April 30, 2024, volume 8, page 151, lines 14–16.
Trial 21 mentionTrial 1 Verdict Slip — Case 22-1117 — Verdict slip for Case 22-1117 including lesser-included charges, as presented to the jury in Trial 1.
Trial 11 mentionTrial 2 Amended Verdict Slip — Amended verdict slip issued in Trial 2, revised to clarify that a guilty finding on a lesser-included offense does not constitute a conviction on the overall charge, with step-by-step instructions for jurors.
Trial 21 mentionTrooper Prince Report of McCabe Interview (February 1, 2022) — Trooper Prince's report documenting a February 1, 2022 interview with Jennifer McCabe.
Trial 21 mentionTrooper Prince/Keefe Report of Roberts Interview (February 1, 2022) — A report authored by Troopers Prince and Keefe documenting their February 1, 2022 interview with night-of witness Kerry Roberts.
Trial 21 mentionTully Police Report — February 10, 2022 Search — Lieutenant Brian Tully's police report dated February 10, 2022 documenting the January 29, 2022 evidence search.
Trial 11 mentionTully Report on McCabe–Proctor Relationship — Lieutenant Brian Tully's interview report regarding Jennifer McCabe's relationship with the Proctor family.
Trial 11 mentionUNSW Study on Serum NAD Levels in MS (2013) — Peer-reviewed article from the University of New South Wales dated August 21, 2013, examining serum NAD levels in multiple sclerosis patients.
Trial 21 mentionVerizon Subscriber Information — Read's Phone (ending 9554) — Verizon subscriber records confirming Karen Read as the subscriber for the phone number ending in 9554 whose records were analyzed.
Trial 11 mentionVeterinary Records for Dog Chloe/Cora — Four pages of veterinary records for the dog known as Chloe or Cora, containing no new owner's name or new name and no transfer or rehoming documentation.
Trial 21 mentionVideo Clips 19 and 20 (Admitted Evidence) — Video clips previously played for the jury and moved into evidence at the start of Gallerani's testimony proceeding.
Trial 21 mentionWaterfall Bar Receipts, Jan. 28, 2022 (Three-Page Document) — A three-page set of receipts from the Waterfall Bar dated January 28, 2022, corroborating patronage at the bar on the night in question. Admitted without objection.
Trial 11 mentionWaterfall Receipt (Exhibit 54) — A receipt introduced as Exhibit 54. Yannetti described it as showing $16.58 in drinks and a $10 tip; Trayers said she had not closely reviewed it and agreed the proposed tip made sense.
Trial 11 mentionWhitley Patient Care Record (Jan. 29, 2022, 9:03 a.m.) — Whitley's 9:03:34 a.m. Section 12 patient record, listing behavioral/psychiatric and anxiety impressions and describing Read as crying and upset but cooperative.
Trial 21 mentionWischnewski Ulcer Medical Reference Photograph — A medical reference photograph, not depicting O'Keefe, showing a stomach with multiple hemorrhages representative of typical Wischnewski (hypothermic) ulcers.
Trial 21 mentionWischnewski Ulcers in Hypothermia — Medical Literature — Medical literature exemplar depicting Wischnewski ulcers in a hypothermia death, used as a baseline comparison.
Trial 21 mentionWolfe 'Direct' Email with Examination Outline (Exhibit 1) — Wolfe's email to Jackson with a proposed direct-examination outline, questions, answers and strategic commentary, admitted as Exhibit 1 in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionWolfe 'Pause' Email to Jackson (Mar. 22, 2024) — Email from Dr. Wolfe to defense attorney Jackson dated March 22, 2024, in which Wolfe halted communications after being instructed to pause by the DOJ.
Trial 21 mentionYannetti's Defense-Opening Preview of Brian Loughran's Expected Testimony — Yannetti's defense opening previewed expected testimony from Brian Loughran: no body on the lawn at about 2:30 a.m. and a Ford Edge near the later recovery area at about 3:30 a.m. Opening statements are not evidence.
Trial 11 mentionForensic Analysis (90)
Welcher Aperture Expert Report and PowerPoint Presentation — Welcher's report and revised PowerPoint covered reconstruction and testing. The report used 12:30:38–12:30:43 for trigger 1162-2; a later presentation used 12:31:38–12:31:43.
Trial 214 mentionsBurgess May 8, 2025 Supplemental (Clock Synchronization) Report — Burgess's May 8 supplemental replaced call-log offsets with three-point-turn synchronization, producing nine offset values and the first scenarios placing phone lock before ignition.
Trial 29 mentionsARCCA February 2024 Joint Biomechanical Report — Wolfe–Rentschler–Kline's February 2024 report. Its conclusion that evidence could not determine the injury cause was contested; the judge noted differing wording on the cover and final pages.
Trial 1Trial 28 mentionsUC Davis Canine DNA Lab Report — Kun's UC Davis report found no canine DNA and detected pig DNA on clothing swabs, while noting qPCR inhibition. It was included in the defense Dropbox disclosure.
Trial 1Trial 27 mentionsBurgess January 30, 2025 Initial Infotainment Report — Burgess's January 30 report on the SD card and call-log clock offsets, including ignition at 12:12:36. It did not reference TechStream events or reach a collision conclusion.
Trial 25 mentionsDr. Elizabeth Laposata Expert Report — Laposata's report, marked D for identification. The court allowed medical-examiner observations while excluding dog-bite and biomechanical portions from her testimony.
Trial 25 mentionsARCCA Vehicle Impact Crash Tests (Tests A–F) — ARCCA videos of Tests A–E and photographs of Test F. Test E used a 24 mph reverse impact with a suspended dummy arm; Test F used a 29 mph Rescue Randy impact. Wolfe said no Test F video was made.
Trial 24 mentionsDiSogra PowerPoint Presentation on Clock Offset Scenarios — DiSogra's May 25, 2025 presentation of 30 possible clock-offset combinations and their effects on phone-lock and vehicle-event timing, updated after Burgess's supplemental.
Trial 24 mentionsMSP Crime Lab Tail Light Swab DNA — Item 3-1.1 — Taillight swab interpreted by Porto as a three-person mixture including O'Keefe and two unknown contributors. He was not asked to compare Kevin Albert or Kenneth Berkowitz.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsO'Keefe Known Blood Standard — Item 8-1.1.1 — O'Keefe's known blood standard, a single-source reference profile tested at the state lab and submitted to Bode for DNA comparisons.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsRentschler ARCCA Biomechanical PowerPoint Presentation — Rentschler's Trial 2 demonstrative with ARCCA analysis and test videos. The court excluded text-heavy opinion slides; the presentation was ultimately marked KKK for identification only.
Trial 24 mentionsTrooper Joseph Paul MSP CARS Reconstruction Report — Paul's CARS report, with imagery, diagrams, distance analysis and a reversal theory involving 30-foot pedestrian projection. Goode denied the report's designation of him as primary investigator.
Trial 1Trial 24 mentionsARCCA Head-Form Drop Test onto Tail Light (15 mph Equivalent) — ARCCA headform drop from 7.5 feet, equivalent to 15 mph, onto an exemplar taillight. The test produced more taillight damage than observed on the subject vehicle.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsBode Technology Tail Light DNA Extract — CCA 2416-0023-E02 — DNA extract from the passenger-side tail light of Karen Read's vehicle (plate 3GC-684), designated Bode Technology item E02 / MSP Crime Lab item 3-1.1, case CCA 2416-0023. The extract yielded a three-person DNA mixture.
Trial 1Trial 23 mentionsBurgess CVs Accurately Showing Degree 'Currently Pursuing' (Exhibits 183 and 184) — Burgess's October/November 2024 and April 2025 CVs, Exhibits 183 and 184, both describing his bachelor's degree as 'currently pursuing.'
Trial 23 mentionsBurgess PowerPoint Presentation (Chalk Exhibit) — Burgess's demonstrative covering vehicle modules, exemplar tests, power events and synchronization. Slides 40, 41 and 43, designated 192A–C, showed GPS and maneuver diagrams.
Trial 23 mentionsDr. John C. Walsh Deputy Medical Examiner Report — Walsh's report called an animal-bite cause of the abrasions highly unlikely, described them as nonspecific and consistent with a rough surface, and noted several possible mechanisms.
Trial 23 mentionsHair Sample from Vehicle with O'Keefe mtDNA — Bode Item E01 — A hair sample submitted to Bode Technology for mitochondrial DNA analysis, designated item E01, recovered from the right rear quarter panel of Karen Read's vehicle where a dent was located.
Trial 13 mentionsRescue Randy 29 mph Impact Test Photographs (Exhibits 218–222) — Five photographs after ARCCA's 29 mph Rescue Randy test, showing arm and torso damage, sleeve glass fragments, the full dummy and the test Lexus's rear damage.
Trial 23 mentionsRichard Green Defense Expert Affidavit — A sworn affidavit filed by defense digital forensics expert Richard Green offering opinions on McCabe's phone data, including an opinion about the 'digest food' search.
Trial 13 mentionsUC Davis Swab Samples from O'Keefe's Shirt — Two swabs from O'Keefe's shirt, including the damaged right sleeve, sent to UC Davis for canine-DNA testing. The garment itself was not sent.
Trial 13 mentionsWhiffin March 2025 Report on O'Keefe's Phone — Whiffin's March 2025 phone report covering GPS accuracy, calls answered to McCabe at 12:14 and 12:29, and unanswered calls to Read beginning at 12:33.
Trial 23 mentionsWhiffin Timeline PowerPoint Presentation — Whiffin's jury presentation of phone-activity timing, compared with his full report. It is distinct from DiSogra's presentation, whose synchronization claim Burgess called potentially misleading.
Trial 23 mentionsBukhenik Buccal Swab Reference Sample — Bode Item R03 — Buccal swab reference sample from Yuri Bukhenik, designated Bode Technology item R03 / CCA 2416-0023-R3, submitted for comparison against the tail light DNA mixture.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsDiSogra Report on Phone Clock Variance — Defense expert Matthew DiSogra's written report arguing that O'Keefe's phone clock consistently ran late relative to real time, offering a clock offset analysis that challenged the Aperture timeline.
Trial 22 mentionsDr. Frank Sheridan Defense Affidavit — A sworn affidavit submitted by defense forensic pathology expert Dr. Frank Sheridan, included in Dr. Russell's review materials.
Trial 12 mentionsHanley Glass Comparison Summary Chart — A visual chart summarizing glass comparison results with match and no-match indicators across multiple evidence categories. Presented as Exhibit WW in Trial 1 and admitted as Exhibit 205 (marked KKK for ID) in Trial 2.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsJessica Hyde Report on O'Keefe's Phone (Report 4) — Hyde's fourth report shows a Health movement interval ending at 12:32:16 a.m. and no further recorded movement until 6:04. Other phone activity continued until at least noon.
Trial 22 mentionsO'Keefe Fingernail Clippings DNA — Items 8-2 and 8-3 — Right and left hand fingernail clippings from John O'Keefe, designated MSP Crime Lab items 8-2 and 8-3, submitted for DNA analysis in Trial 2.
Trial 22 mentionsProctor Buccal Swab Reference Sample — Bode Item R04 — Buccal swab reference sample from Trooper Michael Proctor, designated Bode Technology item R04 / CCA 2416-0023-R4, submitted for comparison against the tail light DNA mixture.
Trial 1Trial 22 mentionsRentschler May 7, 2025 Rebuttal Report — Rentschler's May 7, 2025 rebuttal report, with 26 references critiquing Welcher's paint-transfer test, drop test and vehicle-pedestrian impact conclusions.
Trial 22 mentionsUC Davis Evidence Packaging Photographs — Seven photographs documenting the evidence packaging as received and opened at UC Davis lab, showing sealed packaging with lab case numbers, dates, and Teri Kun's initials. Admitted as Exhibits 74-80 in Trial 1.
Trial 12 mentionsWolfe ARCCA PowerPoint Presentation — Dr. Daniel Wolfe's demonstrative PowerPoint presentation used in Trial 2, covering all six ARCCA impact tests with videos, photographs, acceleration graphs, and delta-V data.
Trial 22 mentionsWolfe Pre-Testimony Q&A Outline with Marginal Notes (Exhibit 3) — Wolfe's pre-testimony outline of scripted questions and answers, sent to defense counsel with marginal notes about wording and anticipated prosecution arguments.
Trial 22 mentions1979 Pedestrian Injury Study (Welcher Reference 25) — A 1979 academic study on pedestrian injuries in motor vehicle collisions, cited as Reference 25 in Dr. Welcher's report.
Trial 21 mention3D Laser Scan of Lexus LX570 (ARCCA Trial 1 Review Material) — Three-dimensional laser scan data of a Lexus LX570 reviewed by ARCCA experts Wolfe and Rentschler as part of the materials underlying their Trial 1 analysis.
Trial 11 mentionAperture Contract with Norfolk County DA — Amendment discussed as permitting up to $325,000 for Aperture. Welcher qualified his view as a non-attorney and said he did not know what the firm had already been paid.
Trial 21 mentionAperture Exemplar Lexus LX570 Infotainment Test Data — 2021 Lexus LX570 exemplar data and synchronized camera footage used by Burgess to assess infotainment timestamps and the timing of power-on events relative to ignition.
Trial 21 mentionAperture Website Biography for Burgess (Exhibit 185) — Aperture website biography for Burgess, admitted as Exhibit 185, listing a completed Mathematics and Business Administration bachelor's degree without an in-progress qualification.
Trial 21 mentionARCCA Tail Light Impact Testing — Intact Diffuser Summary — In closing argument, Alan Jackson said ARCCA's testing showed that, in every test at every speed, the internal diffusers remained intact; this was counsel's advocacy, not underlying expert testimony.
Trial 21 mentionBode Technology and MSP Case Tracking Identifiers — Case tracking numbers for the DNA analysis: Bode Technology lab case number CCA2416-0023 and MSP case number 22-02184.
Trial 21 mentionBuccal Swab Collection — Bukhenik and Proctor — Buccal swab DNA reference samples collected from Sgt. Bukhenik and Trooper Proctor by a certified officer with no connection to the case, subsequently shipped to Bode Technology lab per their protocols.
Trial 11 mentionBurgess CV inaccurately listed the degree as completed (Exhibit 187) — Earlier Burgess CV, Exhibit 187, inaccurately listing a completed degree. He acknowledged it was wrong and said it may have been prepared by him or Aperture.
Trial 21 mentionBurgess October 10, 2024 Data Acquisition Protocol — Burgess's October 10, 2024 proposal for acquiring vehicle-module data, containing megabit/megabyte conversion errors in references to three chips.
Trial 21 mentionCD Accompanying Laposata Report (Exhibit E) — A compact disc accompanying Dr. Laposata's expert report, marked Exhibit E for identification.
Trial 21 mentionDefense Glass Comparison Demonstrative Chart — A defense demonstrative chart presented in chalk during Trial 2 showing four glass categories, used during examination of Christina Hanley.
Trial 21 mentionDiSogra Affidavit Opposing Chip-Off Re-Acquisition — A sworn affidavit filed by Matthew DiSogra opposing Burgess's chip-off re-acquisition of the infotainment board.
Trial 21 mentionDNA Evidence Overview — Tail Light and Shoe — Jackson's Trial 2 opening claimed absent DNA on plastic shards and unidentified male profiles on the taillight and shoe. These were opening-statement claims, not evidence.
Trial 21 mentionDr. Marie Russell Expert Report (December 9, 2024) — Expert report authored by Dr. Marie Russell dated December 9, 2024, with organizational assistance from someone at the defense law firm.
Trial 21 mentionEMPOP International mtDNA Population Database — The EMPOP international population database used by Bode Technology to calculate the statistical rarity of the mitochondrial DNA profile recovered from the hair sample.
Trial 11 mentionExemplar 2021 Lexus LX570 (Welcher Test Vehicle) — A 2021 Lexus LX570 purchased by Dr. Welcher and used by Aperture for grease paint contact tests and low-speed dynamic impact testing.
Trial 21 mentionExemplar Undamaged 2021 Lexus LX570 Tail Light Assembly (Exhibit 250) — An intact exemplar tail light assembly from a 2021 Lexus LX570, mounted with a 3D-printed bracket, with 5mm acrylic diffusers and internal components visible.
Trial 21 mentionFTIR Clear Plastic Comparison Data — Items 3-1 vs 7-18.18 — FTIR (Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy) comparison data for clear plastic comparing item 3-1 (tail light) against item 7-18.18 (clothing debris), admitted as Exhibit 202 in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionFTIR Red Plastic Comparison Data — Items 3-1 vs 7-18.18 — FTIR comparison data for red plastic comparing item 3-1 (tail light) against item 7-18.18 (clothing debris), admitted as Exhibit 203 in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionHartnett Notes on Hoodie Examination Cuts — Criminalist Hartnett's notes documenting cuts and sampling made from O'Keefe's hoodie during lab examination, admitted as Exhibit ZZZ (for identification) in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionHartnett Photographs of O'Keefe Fingernail Clippings — Photographs taken by criminalist Hartnett of the fingernail clippings submitted for John O'Keefe, introduced during Trial 1 testimony.
Trial 11 mentionHartnett Vehicle Paint Standards — Paint standards collected by criminalist Hartnett from damage areas on the rear door and rear bumper of Karen Read's vehicle.
Trial 11 mentionHybrid III Test Arm Weight Photograph — A photograph of the Hybrid III anthropomorphic test arm used in ARCCA's impact testing, showing a weight label reading 9.38 pounds.
Trial 21 mentionJessica Hyde First Forensic Report (May 2023) — Hyde's initial forensic analysis report dated May 2023, covering her examination of McCabe's phone data, including the 2:27:40 timestamp associated with the 'How long to walk 2.4 miles' search term.
Trial 21 mentionJessica Hyde Second Forensic Report (December 2024) — Hyde's December 2024 forensic analysis report addressed a Cellebrite Physical Analyzer parsing change tied to a Google-search timestamp in McCabe's phone data.
Trial 21 mentionLaposata Video E — Mannequin Contact Demonstration — A video showing a mannequin and vehicle contact demonstration, designated Video E, proffered through Dr. Laposata.
Trial 21 mentionLong-Sleeve Shirt Stain L DNA — Item 7-18.14.1 — A DNA sample from stain L located on the back bottom of O'Keefe's long-sleeve shirt, designated MSP Crime Lab item 7-18.14.1.
Trial 21 mentionLong-Sleeve Shirt Unstained Exterior DNA — Item 7-18.17.1 — A DNA sample from an unstained area of the exterior of O'Keefe's long-sleeve shirt, designated MSP Crime Lab item 7-18.17.1.
Trial 21 mentionMaggie Gaffney Chip-Off Report and Photographs — Gaffney's chip-off report and photographs. Burgess later found an unexamined micro-SD card and traced his initial partial-read hypothesis to a bit-versus-byte notation error.
Trial 21 mentionMatthew DiSogra Clock Variance Calculation Chart (Exhibit 190) — A chart prepared by Matthew DiSogra displaying clock-variance calculations between the Lexus infotainment system and other devices.
Trial 21 mentionMatthew DiSogra March 5, 2025 PowerPoint Report (Exhibit 191) — Matthew DiSogra's full PowerPoint presentation dated March 5, 2025, containing the clock variance analysis that Burgess critiqued.
Trial 21 mentionMicrospectrophotometer Red Plastic Comparison Data — Microspectrophotometer comparison data for red plastic comparing item 3-1 (tail light) against item 7-18.18 (clothing debris), admitted as Exhibit 204 in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionO'Keefe Clothing Stain and Fingernail DNA — Porto T1 — Multiple stain samples collected from the front, back, and sleeves of O'Keefe's orange T-shirt and gray long-sleeve shirt, along with fingernail clippings, submitted for DNA analysis.
Trial 11 mentionO'Keefe Mitochondrial DNA Reference Sample (Swab Cutting) — A reference sample in the form of a swab cutting from John O'Keefe, used as the comparison profile for mitochondrial DNA analysis against the hair sample recovered from the vehicle.
Trial 11 mentionPaul Diagram 3 — Debris Field and Area of Impact (Exhibit 587) — Diagram prepared by Trooper Paul depicting the debris field, pedestrian final rest position, and identified area of impact along the roadway at 34 Fairview Road.
Trial 11 mentionPaul Google Maps Route Distance Estimates — Route maps prepared by Trooper Paul using Google Images to estimate travel distances relevant to the night's timeline.
Trial 11 mentionPaul Visibility Analysis with Exemplar Pedestrian — Field visibility test conducted by Trooper Paul using an exemplar pedestrian positioned behind the vehicle to assess whether O'Keefe would have been visible from the driver's perspective.
Trial 11 mentionPhotographs of Jigsaw Glass Fit — Items 3-2 and 7-12 — Photographs documenting the physical jigsaw-fit match between items 3-2 and 7-12, admitted as Exhibits 197A-B in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionPneumatic Cannon Glass-to-Tail-Light Test at 31 mph (Exhibit 213) — Photograph of the results from an ARCCA pneumatic cannon test firing glass at an exemplar tail light at 31 mph, showing minimal resulting damage.
Trial 21 mentionPneumatic Cannon Glass-to-Tail-Light Test at 37 mph (Exhibit 214) — Photograph of the results from an ARCCA pneumatic cannon test firing glass at an exemplar tail light at 37 mph, showing damage generally consistent with the subject tail light.
Trial 21 mentionRear Bumper Apparent-Glass DNA Sample — Item 3-3.1 — A sample collected from apparent glass found on the rear bumper of Karen Read's vehicle, designated MSP Crime Lab item 3-3.1.
Trial 11 mentionRentschler Deposition and Trial Testimony Case List — A 14-page list of Dr. Rentschler's prior depositions and trial testimony appearances, submitted to establish his expert qualifications.
Trial 11 mentionRoberts Retrograde Extrapolation Report — A forensic report by Nicholas Roberts documenting back-calculation from a 9:08 a.m. hospital alcohol result to an estimated BAC at 12:45 a.m., yielding a range of 0.135–0.292.
Trial 11 mentionRoberts Serum-to-Whole-Blood Conversion Report — A forensic report prepared by Nicholas Roberts on May 3, 2022, documenting the mathematical conversion from Karen Read's hospital serum alcohol measurement to a whole blood BAC range of 0.078–0.083.
Trial 11 mentionSeparate Auto-Pedestrian Fatality Case Comparison (Exhibit 206) — A photograph and injury list from a distinct auto-pedestrian fatality case drawn from Dr. Welcher's report materials, admitted as Exhibit 206.
Trial 21 mentionSneaker Right Instep DNA Sample — Item 7-3.1 — A DNA sample taken from the right instep of O'Keefe's sneaker, designated MSP Crime Lab item 7-3.1.
Trial 21 mentionTest F Sweatshirt Damage Photograph (Rescue Randy) — A photograph of the sweatshirt worn by the Rescue Randy dummy after ARCCA's full rear-impact Test F, showing damage across the garment.
Trial 21 mentionTwo Defense Reports Reviewed by Judge Cannone Before Ruling — Two unspecified defense reports provided to Judge Cannone by Jackson and reviewed by the court before a ruling on the admissibility or scope of expert evidence.
Trial 21 mentionVallier Chain-of-Custody Photographs — T1 Exhibits 262–352 — A series of photographs taken by Vallier documenting evidence bags, seals, and individual items as received and examined in the lab, admitted as Exhibits 262–352 in Trial 1.
Trial 11 mentionVallier Lab Analysis Photographs — T2 Exhibits 171A-D–181A-B — Photographs taken by Vallier during lab analysis documenting each evidence item examined, admitted as Exhibits 171A-D through 181A-B in Trial 2.
Trial 21 mentionVallier Mechanical Fit Photographs — T1 Exhibits 384–402 — Photographs taken by Vallier showing mechanical fits between fragments from different evidence items, admitted as Exhibits 384–402 in Trial 1.
Trial 11 mentionVehicle Reverse Demonstration Video (Exhibit 605) — Video demonstration or simulation showing what a vehicle looks like backing up at the speed and distance alleged in the prosecution's reconstruction theory.
Trial 11 mentionWelcher Laser Scans of Read Vehicle, Traverse, and Scene — Three-dimensional laser scan point cloud models of Karen Read's Lexus, O'Keefe's Traverse, the 34 Fairview Road scene, and O'Keefe's residence, created by Aperture for Welcher's analysis.
Trial 21 mentionWhiffin December 2024 Report on Clock Differences — An earlier prosecution report by Ian Whiffin, dated December 2024, addressing clock differences between devices.
Trial 21 mentionWolfe Original DOJ/FBI Report (Trial 1, ~10-12 Pages) — Dr. Daniel Wolfe's original 10-to-12-page report prepared for the DOJ/FBI and provided during Trial 1, submitted without any supporting raw data, videos, or notes, all of which were classified as protected.
Trial 21 mentionNo evidence matches your filters.