Trial 1 Transcript Matthew Kelly
Trial 1 / Day 3 / May 2, 2024
6 pages · 4 witnesses · 2,074 lines
First responders described the snowy emergency response, while cross-examination examined video, statements, and hospital handoff details.
1

REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. LALLY:

2 3:16:19

MR. LALLY: Mr. Kelly, from that video that was just on the screen, you indicated that when you got to the scene, you saw the cruiser and parked sort of behind the cruiser, correct?

3 3:16:28

MR. KELLY: Around the cruiser, yeah.

4 3:16:30

MR. LALLY: So from that video, you didn't see the ambulance that you were driving anywhere in there, correct?

5 3:16:34

MR. KELLY: Correct.

6 3:16:35

MR. LALLY: You have no idea of whether or not you were even on scene at that time that any of those statements that were made in that video were made, correct?

7 3:16:43

MR. KELLY: Correct.

8 3:16:44

MR. LALLY: Now, as far as patient care was concerned, were sort of all of you, being yourself, Firefighter Flematti, Firefighter Nuttall, Firefighter McLaughlin, Firefighter Walsh, Firefighter Woodbury, were you all together all the time or were you doing separate things in separate places during the course of your time on scene?

9 3:17:01

MR. KELLY: Separate things in separate places.

10 3:17:03

MR. LALLY: So fair to say that everything that you heard may not be everything that someone else that was there from your department that day heard, correct?

11 3:17:11

MR. KELLY: Correct.

12 3:17:11

MR. LALLY: And, conversely, something that someone else heard may not be necessarily something that you were in a position to hear that day, correct?

13 3:17:17

MR. KELLY: Correct.

14 3:17:17

MR. LALLY: You also were asked some questions about sort of using the shears and cutting off Mr. O'Keefe's clothing during the ride. Is it your testimony that that was in the back of the ambulance, correct?

15 3:17:27

MR. KELLY: Correct.

16 3:17:27

MR. LALLY: Was that during the transport or was that prior? Would you be utilizing shears on a patient, cutting off clothing while the ambulance is in transit?

17 3:17:37
18 3:17:38

MR. LALLY: So if it was in the back of the ambulance, that would have been prior to the ambulance leaving the scene and going to the Good Samaritan, correct?

19 3:17:49

MR. KELLY: Correct.

20 3:17:49

MR. LALLY: Nothing further.

21 3:17:49

MR. YANNETTI: Your Honor, the only thing I would offer is the video that I played.

22 3:17:59

JUDGE CANNONE: We will do that.

23

(Whereupon, there was a discussion off the record.)

24 3:18:04

MR. YANNETTI: I'm sorry. I was mistaken. It has not been premarked.

25 3:18:16

COURT CLERK: It will be Exhibit 380, Your Honor.

26

(Whereupon, thumb drive re: scene was entered and marked Exhibit No. 380 in Evidence.)

27 3:18:24

JUDGE CANNONE: Thank you.

28 3:18:27

MR. YANNETTI: Thank you.

29 3:18:27

JUDGE CANNONE: All right. So we're all set?

30 3:18:29

MR. LALLY: Yes.

31 3:18:31

MR. YANNETTI: Thank you, Your Honor.

32 3:18:39

JUDGE CANNONE: Thank you. You are all set.

33 3:18:50

MR. KELLY: Thank you.

34

(Whereupon, the witness is excused.)

35 3:18:51

JUDGE CANNONE: Call your next witness.

36 3:18:52

MR. LALLY: Yes, Your Honor. The Commonwealth would call Mr. Francis Walsh to the stand.

Continue to next page Frank Walsh — Direct/Cross