Skip to content
First Criminal Trialtrial-daytrial-dayAdam LallyAlan JacksonElizabeth LittleDavid YannettiBrian AlbertCaitlin AlbertBrian Albert JrcrossredirectrecrossdirectDay 10 - May 13, 2024The judge admitted bulkhead video as Brian Albert's cross-examination addressed prior statements and phone records; Albert family members testified about the gathering at 34 Fairview Road.
← Day 9First Criminal TrialDay 11 →

Day 10 - May 13, 2024

Bulkhead Video Admitted as Albert Family Testimony Continues

Judge Beverly J. Cannone
9Proceedings
5Pages
3Witnesses
3,906Lines
7Sidebars
Day 10 of 35
Appearing:

The judge admitted bulkhead video as Brian Albert's cross-examination addressed prior statements and phone records; Albert family members testified about the gathering at 34 Fairview Road.

Full day summary

Before the jury entered, the judge allowed the defense to show a video of the basement bulkhead and route to the yard after describing the proposed third-party-culprit theory as speculative. During Brian Albert's cross-examination, he acknowledged that part of an earlier statement about never meeting or seeing Karen Read was false, and the defense examined his phone upgrade and calls with Brian Higgins. Brian Albert Jr. and Caitlin Albert later testified that neither John O'Keefe nor Read entered 34 Fairview Road while they were present. The judge deferred until the next morning a ruling on the defense request to use social media photographs involving Katie McLaughlin and Caitlin Albert.

Video thumbnail7:24:00
Watch →

1. Brian Albert — Cross

The judge allowed the defense to show a video of the basement bulkhead and route to the yard before the jury entered. Defense counsel then cross-examined Brian Albert about his prior accounts, 34 Fairview Road, and the timing of his phone trade-in.

→
Procedural
Judge Allows Bulkhead Video After Relevance Objection
48 lines

The judge allowed a defense bulkhead video over the Commonwealth's relevance objection, subject to authentication.

Cross
Brian Albert Cross-Examination Brian Albert Alan Jackson
2488 lines

Defense cross-examined Brian Albert on prior statements, the Waterfall and 34 Fairview Road, his phone upgrade, and calls with Brian Higgins.

5 sidebars inside this proceeding
  1. Grand Jury Terminology LimitsThe court clarified how counsel could distinguish grand-jury proceedings during questioning without using "Commonwealth."
  2. Phone Notice Voir DireThe parties discussed objections to questions about notice concerning a phone and possible advice-of-counsel issues, prompting the judge to order voir dire.
  3. Phone Notice Fifth AmendmentThe court discussed dates surrounding a phone-related notice and required voir dire before questions that could raise a Fifth Amendment issue.
  4. Stipulation on Letter SentThe parties agreed to stipulate that the Commonwealth sent a referenced letter to Mr. Albert on September 23 or 24, 2022, but not that he received it.
  5. Questioning Conduct InstructionThe judge told counsel to calm down while stating that counsel had been given substantial leeway in questioning.

Highlights

2. Brian Albert — Redirect/Recross

Brian Albert returned for redirect and recross examination about the house, basement, phone records, and his preparation meeting with the prosecutor.

→
Redirect
Brian Albert Redirect Examination Brian Albert Adam Lally
156 lines

Brian Albert addressed the basement, bulkhead, phone records, and again testified that John O'Keefe never entered his house.

Recross
Brian Albert Recross on Witness Preparation and Phone Preservation Brian Albert Alan Jackson
71 lines

Brian Albert was questioned about witness preparation, a refreshed recollection of the preparation location, and the timing of his phone upgrade.

← Day 9First Criminal TrialDay 11 →