Skip to content
First Criminal Trialtrial-daytrial-dayNicholas BarrosYuri BukhenikAdam LallyMichael ProctorAlan JacksoncrossredirectrecrossdirectDay 22 - June 10, 2024The court addressed defense expert disclosures as Bukhenik testified about the sally port video, Barros described the Lexus, and Proctor acknowledged unprofessional texts.
← Day 21First Criminal TrialDay 23 →

Day 22 - June 10, 2024

Expert Disclosure Rulings, Sally Port Video Testimony, and Proctor's Text Messages

Judge Beverly J. Cannone
12Proceedings
5Pages
3Witnesses
2,977Lines
17Sidebars
Day 22 of 35
Appearing:

The court addressed defense expert disclosures as Bukhenik testified about the sally port video, Barros described the Lexus, and Proctor acknowledged unprofessional texts.

Full day summary

The court required additional defense expert disclosures, found the ARCCA materials insufficient to define proposed expert testimony, and ordered voir dire before the experts could testify. Sergeant Yuriy Bukhenik testified about the mirrored sally port video, its motion-triggered gaps, and the source of the inverted version shown to the jury. Dighton Sergeant Nicholas Barros described the Lexus's cracked right-rear taillight when police retrieved it. Trooper Michael Proctor described the investigation and evidence collection, acknowledged derogatory personal texts about Karen Read as unprofessional and regrettable, and denied that they affected the investigation.

Video thumbnail7:30:25
Watch →

2. Yuri Bukhenik — Cross/Redirect/Recross

Sergeant Yuriy Bukhenik faced further questioning about the sally port video, his medical examiner report, and early statements attributed to Karen Read.

→
Cross
Yuriy Bukhenik Cross-Examination on Sally Port Video Yuri Bukhenik Alan Jackson
518 lines

Bukhenik was questioned about the mirrored sally port video, its limited runtime, and gaps in the footage; an inverted version was admitted as Exhibit 542.

3 sidebars inside this proceeding
  1. Video Timestamp and Runtime StipulationCounsel discussed the video’s start and end times and its five-minute, 51-second runtime, while the judge declined to have the witness perform a demonstration.
  2. Witness Viewing of VideoThe judge confirmed that the witness could view the video after counsel agreed to that approach.
  3. Video Versions and Proctor TextsCounsel discussed an inverted video version, exhibit XX, and proposed text-message material for Trooper Proctor’s cross-examination, including materials involving Detective Albert.
Redirect
Yuri Bukhenik - Redirect Yuri Bukhenik Adam Lally
135 lines

Bukhenik addressed the mirrored sally port video, denied handling the taillight area, and explained his initial report to the medical examiner.

1 sidebar inside this proceeding
  1. Redirect Question on TaillightCounsel disputed whether a redirect question about the taillight was within scope after cross-examination, and the judge did not allow the question while permitting argument.
Recross
Yuri Bukhenik - Recross Yuri Bukhenik Alan Jackson
60 lines

Bukhenik was questioned about his OCME report, the documentation for reported statements attributed to Read, and the source of the inverted sally port video.

Highlights

4. Michael Proctor — Direct

Trooper Michael Proctor described the early investigation, evidence collection, and damage to Karen Read’s Lexus, then acknowledged unprofessional and regrettable texts about Read.

→
Direct
Michael Proctor - Direct Examination Michael Proctor Adam Lally
1544 lines

Proctor described the evidence collection and vehicle processing, then acknowledged derogatory personal texts about Read while denying they affected his investigation.

9 sidebars inside this proceeding
  1. Shoe Search Investigation TestimonyThe defense objected to testimony about pedestrians being thrown from shoes in crashes, and the judge allowed it as relating to investigative steps.
  2. Laser Pointer Vehicle ContactThe defense objected to a witness using a laser pointer to identify a vehicle-contact area shown on video, and the judge prohibited further questioning on that point.
  3. Instruction on Stricken TestimonyCounsel discussed struck testimony concerning "deleted videos" and whether further clarification was needed; the judge chose a general instruction not to consider stricken material.
  4. Review of Bias Text MessagesThe defense objected to the Commonwealth’s planned use of text messages concerning bias, and the judge requested copies to review during a jury break.
  5. Relevance Objection to Text EvidenceThe judge overruled the defense relevance objection to the Commonwealth’s proposed evidence and allowed counsel to state the objection for the record.
  6. Text Messages on DirectThe defense renewed its objection to the Commonwealth presenting text messages on direct examination, and the judge overruled it before discussing expert scheduling.
  7. Expert Voir Dire SchedulingThe defense asked to conduct expert voir dire and possible testimony before its case to avoid repeated travel costs, and the judge said she would consider it.
  8. Unused Text-Message SetThe parties discussed a text-message set that the defense did not intend to use, and the Commonwealth agreed to move on from it.
  9. Text Message Page ReviewThe parties reviewed proposed text-message excerpts; the judge allowed one communication but excluded three lines from page 2646 during the Commonwealth’s case in chief.
sidebar
Scheduling Phone Check Michael Proctor Adam Lally
8 lines

The judge and defense counsel briefly addressed scheduling, and the judge directed counsel to retrieve his phone to check availability.

sidebar
Expert and Witness Scheduling Michael Proctor Adam Lally
69 lines

The court coordinated witness and expert availability, planning to continue the Commonwealth’s case and reserve possible time for a medical doctor and other experts.

Procedural
Procedural
2 lines

Highlights

← Day 21First Criminal TrialDay 23 →