Katie McLaughlin - Redirect/Recross - Day 9

Six witnesses testify on Day 9, headlined by paramedic Katie McLaughlin's account of Karen Read's repeated 'I hit him' statement at the scene and a withering defense attack on the documentation and integrity of both the BAC evidence and the Fairview Road evidence collection.

← Day 8

Day 10 →

Redirect Line 1

Recross Line 54

Redirect

1 4:29:44

JUDGE CANNONE: Mr. Brennan, can you do a redirect in 5 minutes?

2 4:29:50

MR. BRENNAN: I can. Ma'am, when Mr. Jackson would show you part of your testimony from a prior proceeding, was he leaving something out when he was showing you that — asking you questions?

3 4:30:08

JUDGE CANNONE: Sustained.

4 4:30:08

MR. BRENNAN: When he asked you about whether you knew Caitlin Albert and you said you went to high school with her, did you immediately then answer questions describing that relationship?

5 4:30:20

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Correct.

6 4:30:20

MR. BRENNAN: [unintelligible] Did he also ask you immediately other questions about the relationship?

7 4:30:25

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I explained the relationship over and over again throughout the testimony.

8 4:30:30

MR. BRENNAN: In fact, you described the relationship over 20 times, didn't you?

9 4:30:34

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I'm sure it was that many.

10 4:30:36

MR. BRENNAN: You didn't simply just say somebody named Kate — "I went to high school with somebody named Caitlin Albert." You didn't leave it at that, did you?

11 4:30:48

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: No, I didn't.

12 4:30:49

MR. BRENNAN: Do you remember saying "I would say more acquaintances, not close friends"?

13 4:30:53

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Right.

14 4:30:54

MR. BRENNAN: You remember immediately saying after that "I would say we had mutual friends. We might see each other occasionally because of mutual friends, but we don't have a one-on-one friendship or hang out regularly."

15 4:31:07

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Right.

16 4:31:07

MR. BRENNAN: I'm going to move on. You remember many more statements after that initial answer where you describe the relationship.

17 4:31:14

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes.

18 4:31:15

MR. BRENNAN: Similarly, you were asked about a meeting with the state troopers.

19 4:31:19

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes.

20 4:31:19

MR. BRENNAN: And the attorney asked you a question about your memory — or suggesting that Mr. Albert set up the meeting. You remember those questions?

21 4:31:29

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes.

22 4:31:29

MR. BRENNAN: You were asked questions just like that before at the last hearing, weren't you?

23 4:31:34

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes.

24 4:31:34

MR. BRENNAN: Remember being asked about who set up the meeting and you saying that you didn't recall?

25 4:31:40

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes.

26 4:31:40

MR. BRENNAN: And then you remember being asked about whether a completely different officer set up the meeting and you said "I don't remember exactly how it was set up."

27 4:31:50

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes.

28 4:31:51

MR. BRENNAN: Followed by — so that was my next question. "You may have told me this. Do you have any recollection who set that interview up?" And you said you didn't.

29 4:32:02

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Right.

30 4:32:02

MR. BRENNAN: And you were specifically asked, "Does the name Kevin Albert sound familiar?"

31 4:32:06

MR. JACKSON: Objection.

32 4:32:07

MR. BRENNAN: Do you remember saying no?

33 4:32:09

JUDGE CANNONE: Objection sustained.

34 4:32:09

MR. BRENNAN: Do you remember when you were asked at the last hearing, "Does the name Kevin Albert sound familiar?" Do you remember what you told attorney Jackson?

35 4:32:21

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I told him no.

36 4:32:23

MR. BRENNAN: And then you were asked, "Do you know Kevin Albert?" Do you remember your response?

37 4:32:30

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I said no.

38 4:32:32

MR. BRENNAN: When you were there trying to help the gentleman that was on the ground, did you know this would become a homicide investigation?

39 4:32:38

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: No.

40 4:32:38

MR. BRENNAN: Did anybody tell you this was a homicide?

41 4:32:40

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: No.

42 4:32:41

MR. BRENNAN: In fact, when the defendant spoke to you and you were simply trying to get background information to help Mr. O'Keefe — when she told you "I hit him, I hit him" — did she say that she hit him with something?

43 4:32:52

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: No.

44 4:32:52

MR. BRENNAN: Did you know whether it was with a fist or a foot?

45 4:32:56

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: No.

46 4:32:56

MR. BRENNAN: Or a Lexus?

47 4:32:57

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: No.

48 4:32:57

MR. BRENNAN: You mentioned this was not part of your role to investigate. Why didn't you persist? Why didn't you follow up and ask more questions about that statement? What about the situation and the dynamics caused you not to ask questions? Why didn't you persist in getting more information from the defendant when she said, "I hit him. I hit him."

49 4:33:14

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I just felt bad for her at the time. It was a very disturbing scene and I did not want to push further down that road. It's not my job and I didn't feel comfortable doing it.

50 4:33:46

MR. BRENNAN: No. But how do you remember she made those statements?

51 4:33:54

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I won't ever forget those statements.

52 4:34:00

MR. BRENNAN: I have no further questions.

53 4:34:04

JUDGE CANNONE: Anything, Mr. Jackson?

Recross

54 4:34:07

MR. JACKSON: Very briefly. That was a disturbing scene, right?

55 4:34:09

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes.

56 4:34:09

MR. JACKSON: An emotional scene.

57 4:34:10

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes. Yes.

58 4:34:11

MR. JACKSON: A lot of people for a lot of reasons, right?

59 4:34:14

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes.

60 4:34:14

MR. JACKSON: And that's when things start getting missed. When emotion starts playing a role, correct?

61 4:34:19

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I — that's when details start getting missed. I guess it depends on the situation, right?

62 4:34:24

MR. JACKSON: But this was a disturbing, emotional, upsetting scene even for you. Correct.

63 4:34:28

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I felt that for a civilian to see it, it was very disturbing for them.

64 4:34:33

MR. JACKSON: Probably wasn't great for you either, was it?

65 4:34:35

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: It's not.

66 4:34:36

MR. JACKSON: Yeah. And your testimony is you never heard my client say, "Could I hit him? Did I hit him?" Correct. You never heard that.

67 4:34:43

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I didn't hear those questions. No.

68 4:34:45

MR. JACKSON: What you heard was "I hit him." Is that right?

69 4:35:21

PARENTHETICAL: [Objection — withdrawn]

70 4:35:21

MR. JACKSON: Finally, with regard to Kevin Albert, did Trooper Proctor tell you during that interview that he had texted with Trooper — I'm sorry — with Officer Kevin Albert about setting up your interview?

71 4:34:49

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: I heard "I hit him" repeatedly.

72 4:34:51

MR. JACKSON: And changing gears for a quick second. I'm almost finished. You did ultimately start talking about your relationship in more detail with Caitlin under my questioning, didn't you? After that first — is that right?

73 4:35:06

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Yes.

74 4:35:07

MR. JACKSON: That's when I started showing you photographs. Correct.

75 4:35:10

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Was that — was that when you were shown photographs? I don't know. I described it so many times I — I don't remember.

76 4:35:21

MR. JACKSON: But you — you knew I had — that I was going to ask you about —

77 4:36:21

JUDGE CANNONE: Court is back in session. You may be seated. I apologize for that, folks. Nobody likes wasting your time.

78 4:35:45

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Tell you that? I have no knowledge of that.

79 4:35:48

MR. JACKSON: Did he tell you that the reason we're here, the reason we set this is because Kevin Albert texted me that he had already coordinated with you?

80 4:35:59

MS. MCLAUGHLIN: Never. No.

81 4:36:00

MR. JACKSON: Thank you.

82 4:36:01

JUDGE CANNONE: It's all right. All right, Miss McLaughlin, you are all set. Joe, I appreciate you going a little later. Until lunch, witness. So, why don't we do that? I'll give you 45 minutes.

83 4:36:14

COURT OFFICER: All rise for the court, please. Follow me.

Summary

This page covers Katie McLaughlin's final examinations on Day 9. On redirect, ADA Brennan rehabilitates her testimony by establishing the extent of her prior characterization of Caitlin Albert and explaining why, in her paramedic role, she did not pursue or document Karen Read's 'I hit him' statement as an investigator would. Jackson's brief recross focuses on whether the emotional scene conditions might have affected her certainty about the specific language, while revisiting the Albert relationship; McLaughlin is then excused.

Redirect Katie McLaughlin (Hank Brennan)

On redirect, ADA Hank Brennan addresses two lines of attack from Jackson's cross-examination. First, Brennan establishes that McLaughlin did not merely identify Caitlin Albert as a high school acquaintance and leave it there — she described the relationship 'over 20 times' during prior testimony, characterizing Albert as an acquaintance rather than a close friend, with no one-on-one friendship. Second, Brennan rehabilitates McLaughlin's failure to document or follow up on Karen Read's 'I hit him' statement by eliciting that McLaughlin did not know this was a homicide investigation, that Read never specified what she hit O'Keefe with, and that McLaughlin's role as a paramedic was medical care, not investigation. The proceeding concludes with McLaughlin's emotional statement that she will never forget Read's words.

Legal Significance

Brennan rehabilitates McLaughlin's credibility on two fronts Jackson attacked: that she concealed her Albert connection (she described it extensively) and that her failure to document Read's statement undermines its reliability (she was a paramedic, not an investigator, with no reason to treat it as evidence).

Examination Style

Hank Brennan: Systematic rehabilitation addressing each defense attack point in sequence — first the Albert relationship, then the Kevin Albert meeting setup, then the undocumented statement — building to an emotional close with McLaughlin's memorable final answer.

Key Quotes

"I explained the relationship over and over again throughout the testimony."
— Katie McLaughlin Counters Jackson's implication that McLaughlin minimized or concealed her connection to Caitlin Albert

"I just felt bad for her at the time. It was a very disturbing scene and I did not want to push further down that road. It's not my job and I didn't feel comfortable doing it."
— Katie McLaughlin Explains why McLaughlin did not follow up on Read's statement — humanizes the witness and reinforces her non-investigative role

"I won't ever forget those statements."
— Katie McLaughlin Emotional anchor for the prosecution's case — addresses the defense argument that failure to document means unreliable memory

"Did you know whether it was with a fist or a foot? ... Or a Lexus?"
— Hank Brennan Establishes that Read's statement was ambiguous and McLaughlin had no reason to interpret it as a vehicular confession

Topics

McLaughlin's prior testimony describing Caitlin Albert relationship as acquaintanceNumber of times McLaughlin described the Albert relationship in prior proceedingsKevin Albert and interview setup — McLaughlin's denial of knowing himMcLaughlin's lack of awareness this was a homicide investigationKaren Read's statement 'I hit him' without specifying mechanismWhy McLaughlin did not follow up or document Read's statementMcLaughlin's paramedic role versus investigative responsibility

Recross Katie McLaughlin (Alan Jackson)

In a short recross of approximately 30 utterances, defense attorney Alan Jackson pursues two lines. First, he gets McLaughlin to agree the scene was disturbing and emotional, then pivots to suggest that such conditions cause details to be missed — setting up a contrast with her certainty that Read said 'I hit him' rather than 'Did I hit him?' or 'Could I hit him?' McLaughlin maintains she heard 'I hit him' repeatedly and never heard those alternative phrasings. Jackson then briefly touches on her expanded testimony about Caitlin Albert before returning to whether Trooper Proctor told McLaughlin that Officer Kevin Albert had coordinated her interview. McLaughlin denies any knowledge of this, and the witness is excused.

Legal Significance

Jackson uses the emotional chaos of the scene to undermine the reliability of McLaughlin's recollection of Read's exact words — a critical distinction between a confession ('I hit him') and a question ('Did I hit him?'). The Kevin Albert coordination question plants the suggestion that McLaughlin's interview was arranged through the Albert family network rather than standard investigative channels.

Examination Style

Alan Jackson: Brief, targeted recross hitting two discrete points — scene chaos undermining witness reliability on the key statement, and Kevin Albert's role in coordinating the Proctor interview — without overextending.

Key Quotes

"And that's when things start getting missed. When emotion starts playing a role, correct?"
— Alan Jackson Sets up the argument that McLaughlin's certainty about Read's exact words is unreliable given the chaotic scene.

"I heard "I hit him" repeatedly."
— Katie McLaughlin McLaughlin's final word on the central disputed statement — she maintains it was a declaration, not a question.

"Did he tell you that the reason we're here, the reason we set this is because Kevin Albert texted me that he had already coordinated with you?"
— Alan Jackson Implies Trooper Proctor's interview of McLaughlin was arranged through Canton police officer Kevin Albert rather than through normal channels.

"Never. No."
— Katie McLaughlin Flat denial of any knowledge that Kevin Albert coordinated her interview with Proctor.

Credibility Challenges

Katie McLaughlin — Jackson argues the disturbing, emotional scene would cause details to be missed, undermining McLaughlin's certainty about Read's exact words.
Katie McLaughlin — Jackson implies McLaughlin's interview with Trooper Proctor was coordinated through Officer Kevin Albert, suggesting an Albert family connection to how her testimony was gathered.

Topics

emotional chaos at the scene and its effect on memory reliabilitydistinction between 'I hit him' as statement versus questionKevin Albert coordinating McLaughlin's interview with Trooper ProctorMcLaughlin's expanded testimony about Caitlin Albert relationship

← Katie McLaughlin - Cross 7 of 9 Paul Gallagher - Direct →