← All EvidenceOpeningCommonwealth Opening Statement Adam Lally DirectSteven Saraf — Direct Examination Steven Saraf Adam Lally OpeningCommonwealth Opening Statement: Alleged Vehicle Strike and Data Timeline Hank Brennan DirectTimothy Nuttall — Direct Examination Tim Nuttall Hank Brennan CrossTim Nuttall - Cross Tim Nuttall Alan Jackson CrossTim Nuttall Cross-Examination Continued Tim Nuttall Alan Jackson RedirectTim Nuttall - Redirect Tim Nuttall Hank Brennan RecrossTim Nuttall - Recross Tim Nuttall Alan Jackson
Video Evidence
Cruiser 683 Dashcam — Saraf, 34 Fairview Scene
Cruiser 683 footage from 34 Fairview on January 29, 2022, showing blizzard conditions, people around O'Keefe, scene tape and Read's damaged taillight.
About
A central piece of prosecution evidence used across both trials to establish the timeline of first responder arrival, scene conditions, and the positions of key witnesses including Karen Read. In T2, timestamped versions were used to precisely anchor witness statements about when Read made alleged incriminating remarks, while the defense used the same footage to challenge the credibility of those accounts.
Dashcam footage from Officer Saraf's Cruiser 683 recorded at 34 Fairview Road on the morning of January 29, 2022. Captures road and weather conditions during the blizzard, arrival at the scene, the parked vehicle, and the three women with O'Keefe on the ground. Also documents officers setting up crime scene tape and shows Karen Read's damaged tail light.