Commonwealth v. Read — Trial Archive
Person Shanon Burgess Trial 2Aperture LLC digital forensics examiner who analyzed Lexus infotainment and phone timing data. ← All People
🔬 Expert Witness · Aperture LLC

Shanon Burgess

Courtroom still of Shanon Burgess.

Aperture LLC digital forensics examiner who analyzed Lexus infotainment and phone timing data.

Trial 2
1,510 lines 6 proceedings

About

Shanon Burgess examined data from Karen Read’s Lexus. Burgess initially questioned whether an earlier examination of three chips had been incomplete, but acknowledged on cross-examination that a bit-versus-byte conversion error affected that assessment and that the chips had been fully acquired. Burgess said the error was only part of the basis for the original protocol. Burgess later found an unexamined SD card in the infotainment module and recovered timestamped data that Burgess interpreted, through exemplar testing, as power-on and power-off events. Burgess used a three-point turn to compare the Lexus clock with John O’Keefe’s iPhone clock and calculated a 21-to-29-second variance. Applying that variance, Burgess placed the end of a ten-second vehicle-data capture between 12:32:04 and 12:32:12 a.m. on the phone clock, a range that included the phone’s reported 12:32:09 last user interaction. Burgess cautioned that the end of the capture did not necessarily mark the end of the backing maneuver. Defense questioning challenged the choice of clock alignment and the timing of Burgess’s supplemental analysis. Burgess disputed the defense expert’s calculations and distinguished call timestamps from when the Lexus was off from later infotainment-to-phone comparisons. Cross-examination also addressed Burgess’s credentials. Burgess acknowledged having no bachelor’s degree although an Aperture biography, LinkedIn profile and older CV contained degree information Burgess described as erroneous or outdated. CVs filed in this case said Burgess was currently pursuing a degree. A CV filed in a Texas federal case listed an incorrect degree without that qualifier; Burgess said its 2024 date had been an expected graduation date and that Burgess had neither submitted nor seen the document before it was filed.

Trial Record (6)

Trial 2 Retrial Apr 22, 2025 – Jun 18, 2025 6 proceedings

Day 18

Direct Shanon Burgess - Direct Shanon Burgess Hank Brennan 5 highlights 335 lines spoken
Summary

Digital forensics expert Shanon Burgess testifies about recovering previously unacquired data from the Lexus infotainment SD card, identifying infotainment power on/off timestamps, and calculating clock variance between the Lexus and John O'Keefe's iPhone.

Highlights (5)
Quote

“So initial impressions were that data was missed from the initial download.”

Records Burgess's initial impression, which he later testified resulted from a capital-B/lowercase-b notation error and corrected through further review; it does not establish that Gaffney failed to recover available data from the three chips.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Quote

“So at that point I concluded that the data that we were missing was most likely stored on this SD card.”

Identifies the overlooked SD card on the infotainment module as the source of critical missing timestamp data.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Quote

“There was a claim of attempting to synchronize those two clocks that I believed was potentially misleading.”

Burgess said he viewed a clock-synchronization claim in a PowerPoint presentation as potentially misleading; he later identified that presentation as Mr. Dogra's, rather than a Whiffin report.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Show 1 more
Quote

“The clock variance is between 21 and 29 seconds.”

Quantifies Burgess's stated variance between the Lexus internal clock and O'Keefe's iPhone. Applied to the second TechStream event, the resulting range concerns the end of its 10-second capture window, not necessarily the entire backing event.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Cross Shanon Burgess - Cross Shanon Burgess Robert Alessi 3 highlights 497 lines spoken
Summary

Defense attorney Alessi challenged Burgess's degree representations, capacity-conversion errors affecting three chips in his protocol, and the timing and basis of his mid-trial supplemental report.

Highlights (3)
Quote

“This would be the only one that I recall.”

Burgess said this was the only midtrial supplemental report he recalled in about 10 years; he explained that a March presentation prompted additional analysis.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶

Day 19

Cross Shanon Burgess - Cross (Continued) Shanon Burgess Robert Alessi 2 highlights 312 lines spoken
Summary

Defense attorney Alessi continues cross-examining digital forensics expert Shanon Burgess, challenging his timeline accuracy, methodology choices, and the significance of TechStream trigger events.

Highlights (2)
Quote

“That adjustment is the only adjustment that can be applied due to the data.”

Burgess concedes the three-point turn method is the only way to place the TechStream event after the phone lock, though he frames it as a data limitation rather than bias.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Redirect Shanon Burgess - Redirect Shanon Burgess Hank Brennan 5 highlights 305 lines spoken
Summary

Prosecution rehabilitates Burgess on redirect, addressing credential criticism and defending his clock synchronization methodology over defense expert Dogra's approach.

Highlights (5)
Quote

“No one. My job is to assist the jury. Assisting the jury means presenting all the information.”

Burgess asserts independence from prosecution influence, countering defense suggestions of bias.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Quote

“So those timestamps are not coming from the vehicle. They're coming from Mrs. Read's iPhone — or the defendant's iPhone.”

Burgess distinguished early call rows recorded while the Lexus was off, which he said reflected iPhone-to-iPhone timestamps, from later powered-on infotainment-to-iPhone comparisons. He said the later times were accurate, agreed with a 5:00 a.m. calculation, but considered it temporally distant from the 12:30 period at issue.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Quote

“GPS point 154 is a GPS point that occurs just before the three-point turn starts.”

Directly contradicts Dogra's use of GPS 154 as representing the end of the three-point turn, which was the foundation of one of Dogra's variance calculations.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Quote

“That is 21 to 29 seconds.”

Burgess's final clock variance opinion, placing the adjusted Techstream backing event at 12:32:04-12:32:12 on O'Keefe's phone clock — overlapping with the 12:32:09 last user interaction.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Show 1 more
Quote

“So again, the Techstream event ends somewhere between 12:32:04 and 12:32:12. But that does not represent that the backing maneuver has ended — just the recorded data has ended.”

Places the 12:32:09 last user interaction within the adjusted 12:32:04-to-12:32:12 Techstream recorded-data-end range. Burgess said the end of that recording window did not determine when the backing maneuver ended.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Recross Shanon Burgess - Recross Shanon Burgess Robert Alessi 2 highlights 52 lines spoken
Summary

Robert Alessi confronts Shanon Burgess with a federal court filing from a Texas case containing an incorrect CV line without the 'currently pursuing' qualifier; Burgess later said he neither submitted nor saw the document before it was filed.

Highlights (2)
Quote

“Sure. So that is an error. Clearly, BGS stands for bachelor of general studies, and that should have "with minor in mathematics and business administration."”

Burgess described the listed title as an error, explaining that BGS stands for Bachelor of General Studies and that the line should identify minors in mathematics and business administration.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Quote

“Correct. Yes, it was.”

Burgess agreed that an incorrect statement about his educational background was filed in federal court after answering that he was not aware of such a filing; on re-redirect, he said he had neither submitted nor seen the document before filing.

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Redirect Shanon Burgess - Re-Redirect Shanon Burgess Hank Brennan 4 highlights 9 lines spoken
Summary

Hank Brennan conducted brief re-redirect establishing that Burgess did not personally file the Texas federal court CV and that it listed a 2024 expected graduation date when filed in 2023.

Highlights (4)
Quote

“As most people can probably relate, work, family, and life many times get in the way.”

Humanizes the incomplete degree — reframes it from credential fraud to relatable life circumstances

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶

Locations Touched By This Testimony

34 Fairview Road 1 proc Canton Police Department 1 proc